Elizabeth did not say anything. She did not go to him. She stood where she was and let him say it because she understood that nobody had ever let him say it before.
“I have heard every word of what they say about me,” he said, “that we fought on the tor, that I left him, that I went up there and pushed him. None of it is true, and none of it matters. I was the last man to speak to him in his life, and what I said was that he was a fool. And I sat over my wine for an hour while he lay in the snow.”
He put his hand flat on the cold glass.
“That is the truth you asked for. I would have told it in any court in England. Nobody asked me. And I did not think I had the right to defend myself.”
“Was there anybody else?” she asked. “Up there that night?”
He turned his head and looked at her for the first time.
“Why do you ask that?”
“Because you said once in London that you had seen a dog like Juno before. I saw your face when she went to you on the step. I have wondered ever since.”
He looked down at the old dog lying at his feet. For a moment she thought he would not answer.
“There was a light,” he said slowly, “on the far side of the gully when I was climbing out with him. A lantern and a pale dog in front of it standing on the rocks in the snow looking down at me. And then the snow came across between us and they were gone. I have never known whether I saw it or dreamed it. I was in no state to know what I saw.”
He was quiet.
“I told myself I dreamed it. A man does not like to think somebody stood there and watched him fail.”
Elizabeth crossed the gallery. Then she took his hand, the one that lay on the glass, and held it in both of hers. It was very cold. He did not pull away. He did not grip her back either.
At first, he only let her hold it, as though he did not quite believe she meant to, and then slowly his fingers closed round hers, and held on hard. They stood like that at the window with the moon on the snow and the old dog at their feet and neither of them said anything at all for a long while. She did not tell him what she was thinking. She was thinking of Matthew and of the winter before she married him, which he had never spoken of. She was thinking that Juno had been a young dog then, palecoated and quick, and that her ruff had not been gray.
She was thinking of a man who had said once over his supper that the Duke was not what people said, and that it was not his to tell. She was not ready to think any further than that. She did not want to hope for something and be wrong. The Dowager Duchess called at the hall on Christmas Eve morning with a holly wreath for the door and a basket of oranges. She came into the bake house of all places in her furs and stood among the flour sacks and the cooling racks and exclaimed at everything.