“She does it every year,” Bertha said behind her, wiping her hands. It was the longest speech Elizabeth had heard her make.
“Tea and sugar and a shilling and a word with each of them at the door. She is very sorry for them all. She is very sorry for herself. And by the time the footman is home again, the whole parish has heard that she cannot bear to look up at this house because of what was done to her husband.”
Bertha folded the cloth and laid it down.
“I was in this house that night, madam. I was carrying the soup up, and I heard her in the passage before dinner, talking low to the old duke, and I saw him go white as the cloth. I never knew what she said. But I think you had better ask him.”
Elizabeth asked him that night. She found him in the long gallery after the house had gone to bed, standing at the end window with a candle on the sill beside him. The snow had stopped. A white moon stood over the moor.
In its light, the high tor above the valley was as plain as day, black and silver, with the deep cleft of a gully running down its side like a crack in a plate. He did not turn when she came. Juno had come with her, as Juno now went everywhere with her, and the old dog walked past them both, and lay down on the boards at his feet with a sigh.
“I said I would ask you for the truth when I wanted it,” Elizabeth said. “I want it now, not for the parish. For me.”
He did not answer at once. When he spoke, it was not to her. It was to the tor.
“We quarreled at dinner. He was drinking as he did every night that winter. Something had happened between him and Sophronia before we sat down. I never learned what. He was half mad with it. He would not say what it was. I told him across the table that he was a drunkard and a fool, and that he would kill himself on that horse. He threw his glass at the wall and went out to the stables.”
The Duke’s voice did not change. It went on level and quiet like a man reading a list of the dead.
“I did not go after him. I sat at that table and finished my wine because I was angry and because I had said it before, and he had always come home. It was the better part of an hour before I took a lantern and went out. By then the snow was so thick I could not see my own hand. I found his horse at the moor gate. I found him at the bottom of that gully under the rocks. He was alive. He said something to me. I could not hear it for the wind. I carried him down. And on the way down, he died.”