A good many of them stopped on the path afterwards, too, and touched their hats to the Duke as he went by, awkwardly, the way men do something they have not yet got used to. He touched his own hat in return to each of them, and said good morning, and nothing more. His face did not change, but Elizabeth was holding his arm, and she felt it tremble every time. On the far side of the aisle in the Dower House pew, Sophronia sat in her furs with her prayer book open on her knee and watched it happen. She watched the carrier.

She watched the hats come off on the path. She sat very straight and did the sum in her head again, and this time it did not come out. It was Bramble who found it. On the day after Christmas, she came into the bake house at a gallop with snow on her nose, as she came into every room, and her tail caught the writing slope on its shelf by the window, and swept it to the floor.

It landed on its corner on the flags with a crack. Elizabeth cried out and knelt to pick it up, afraid for the hinges. As she lifted it, a thin strip of wood slid out of the side of the box, where she had never known there was anything but wood. It was a drawer no deeper than her finger, and so cleverly made that she had written on that slope for 5 years without guessing it was there.

Inside it lay a few folded sheets of paper closely written in a hand she knew better than her own. She read it sitting on the bake house floor among the flour sacks with Bramble’s head in her lap and the dogs around her. It was dated in the week after the old Duke died. It was a draft full of crossings out the way Matthew always drafted anything that mattered to him.

“Your Grace,” it began:

“I could not say this at the graveside, and you have shut your door to everybody since, so I write it. I was on the moor that night. My young dog found your brother before you did. I reached the bottom of the gully a little before you came, and he was alive and clear in his mind, and he spoke to me. He said he had ridden out because his wife had told him before dinner what she owed at cards. It was a sum that would have cost him the London house and he had sworn he would put her out of it. He said you had called him a fool at the table and that you were right. Then he took my hand and said, ‘Tell Harry he is not to carry this.’ Those were his words. I heard you coming down the gully with your lantern, and I went for men and a hurdle because I could not carry him alone. When we came up again, you had already brought him down. I am sorry I left you to do it alone. I have given the fair copy of this into Her Grace’s hands at her request, as she tells me, you will receive nobody, and she will send it to you herself. God keep you. You did all that a man could do.”