She remembered the lanterns behind them, a little string of yellow lights bobbing in the white dark and how it frightened her each time one of them went out. And she remembered how it ended. Juno stopped at the lip of the gully under the tor and stood on the rocks in the snow with her white ruff blowing and looked down. Bramble ran up and down the edge and barked and barked.

Rook lay flat at the very brink and whined. The Duke lifted his lantern and held it out over the drop, and far below them, at the bottom of the cliff among the fallen rocks, they saw a dark shape lying half buried in a drift. It moved. It lifted an arm.

“He’s alive,” Elizabeth said.

Her voice did not sound like her own.

“Oh, God, be thanked. He’s alive.”

The men had come up behind them with the ropes. They stood at the lip of the gully and looked down into it, and then they looked at each other, and not one of them moved. It was a long way down, and the sides were sheer black rock, slick with ice, and every soul in that parish knew what had happened at the bottom of it. The carrier had his rope in his hands and could not make his hands use it. He was shaking.

Elizabeth looked at the rock and the ice and the dark, and knew with a cold, clear certainty that she could not go down there. She had no strength for it and no knowledge of it, and if she tried, there would be two to carry up instead of one. The Duke gave her his lantern. He took the end of the carrier’s rope out of the carrier’s hands, and knotted it round his own chest under the arms, and gave the other end to the men.

“There’s a way down on the left,” he said. “A ledge, then a chimney in the rock. I’ve been down it once.”

He looked at the men.

“Hold it. Don’t let go of it until I tell you.”

He went over the edge into the dark. Elizabeth knelt at the lip with the lantern held out as far as she dared, and watched him go down, a little at a time, feeling for the ledge with his boots and the cracks with his bare hands. Twice the snow came across between them and she lost him altogether. Twice it cleared and he was still there. The men behind her held the rope and said nothing.

She heard the carrier praying over and over under his breath the same few words. And then the Duke was at the bottom, kneeling in the drift beside the boy. She heard his voice come up out of the gully, steady and low, saying something she could not catch, and then the boy’s voice answering him. Juno went down to them before anybody could stop her. The old dog found a way of her own, a goat’s way, scrambling and sliding down the far side of the clifff.