The Duke turned away from her to the window. She watched his shoulders and saw that she had hurt him again without meaning to and could not tell how. When he spoke, it was to the glass.

“Last Christmas, I went down to Falcon for the first time since my brother died. I sat in my family’s pew. The parish got up from theirs, a few at a time, and went out into the snow. The curate preached to me and Bertha and the clerk.”

He paused.

“Your husband was very kind to me afterwards. He was the only man in the county who was. Remember that Christmas?”

Elizabeth said, “I was not there. I had a fever. He came home and sat by the fire and would not speak of it.”

“I want to go home.” He said it flatly as though it were a fact about the weather.

“I have a house there that nobody will come to and a parish that will not sit in a church with me and a sister-in-law next door who has spent 6 years making sure that London agrees with them. I am not asking you to like me. I am telling you what I need. If the curate’s widow from Falcon Lair stands beside me at Christmas church in that parish, they will think twice. They loved your husband. They will not believe he left his widow to a murderer.”

He turned round at last and looked at her.

“Marry me, Mrs. Bane. That is the whole of what I want from you. My name mended as far as you are able to mend it. I won’t pretend it is anything kinder.”

It was so plainly said that for a moment she could not answer. She had been proposed to once before in a garden above the Dart by a shy young curate with his hat in his hands, and it had been all hope and stammering. This was different. This was a man laying out the truth on the table between them like a loaf, and letting her see every part of it. She found that she respected him for it more than she would have respected any amount of charm.

“And what would I have?” she asked.

She did not ask it coldly. She wanted him to say it.

“A roof that nobody can shut on you. A kitchen of your own, and nobody in it to tell you how to use it. The dogs go where you go, in any house of mine, and sleep where you choose. An income of your own that I will put beyond my reach and anybody else’s.”

He hesitated and for the first time he seemed less sure of his ground.

“And I will not ask you for anything you do not want to give. It would be a marriage in name. For as long as you wish it to be.”

Elizabeth looked at the old dog on the hearthrug at his feet. Juno had lifted her gray muzzle and was watching her steadily, the way she had watched Matthew at a moor gate in the fog, waiting to be told the way. She thought of the shut doors of London, one after another, and of the oiled click of the last of them. She thought of falcon in the snow and the church she knew better than her own face and the people in it who had got up and walked out. And she thought that a woman with nothing in the world but a bowl and three dogs did not often get to choose what she would be and that she was choosing now with her eyes open.