He heard 11 people in succession pay more than the sum written against their names in the copy folded inside his coat. He heard a man from Tanner’s Walk ask whether anything could be done about his roof, and be told that the estate was not a charity. He heard a fine of 15 shillings laid on a woman for a broken sash that her own landlord’s ladder had broken, and heard her pay it, and heard Dunnage say, kindly, that he would see what might be done, and write nothing down. And he heard over and again the one sentence that had kept the thing standing for 9 years,

“You may see the book, Mr. Dunnage.”

“The book is the estate’s, not yours.”

At a quarter past 9:00 it was her turn. She put her money on the counter, 9 shillings counted out. And she had sold her husband’s watch to do it, which the Duke knew because he had seen the pawn ticket on the mantel and had said nothing, which had cost him more than any silence of his life. And she said,

“9 shillings, Mr. Dunnage, which is my week. And I am here to say before these people that the notice you sent me is not honest, and that I will not pay 10, and that the fine of 2 pounds is for your gutter and not my wall.”

The room went quiet behind her. Dunnage looked up. He was a well-made man of 50, gray, close-shaved, in good black broadcloth, with the particular neatness of a man who has risen and does not intend to be mistaken for what he rose from. And the Duke of Merestead, standing 6 ft behind the woman’s shoulder, understood in that moment precisely why 9 years of beautiful quarterly abstracts had never been questioned. The man looked exactly like what he was pretending to be.

“Mrs. Lidbury,” said Dunnage, “you have no lease.”

“I have my husband’s lease.”

“Your husband is dead, and the lease died with him, and you have been suffered to remain out of consideration for your situation, which I may say has not been met with gratitude.”

He dipped his pen.

“10 shillings from the quarter day. The fine stands.”

“And I am bound to tell you in the hearing of these people, since you have chosen to make it public, that the state of the warehouse wall is the least of what is spoken of in Pie Row. A woman alone in a trade is one thing. A woman who is attended home by a stranger 11 nights together, and who entertains him in her kitchen past midnight.”

“Four nights,” said Selda Lidbury, white to the lips. “And he is paid a shilling, and he has never once crossed my door but with his hat in his hand.”

“Paid,” said Dunnage, and smiled and wrote.

“You will forgive me. I had not understood it was an arrangement of that kind.”

The Duke of Merestead stepped round her. He did it without hurry. He put his hands on the counter, one on either side of the open book, and he leaned in. And he was a very large man, and he had not shaved for 5 days, and there was a healing cut through his left eyebrow. And Hesper Dunnage drew back on his stool.