“Your Grace is a landlord of some 400 houses in this town.”

“411.”

“For how many years?”

“11.”

“And in those 11 years, how many times have you walked down Fettle Street?”

“11,” said the Duke of Merestead. “Once a year, always at night, always alone.”

That was not the answer Mr. Craig had been expecting, and he required a moment to put it away.

“And how many times have you entered your own counting house in Gaunt Street, where your rents are received?”

“Once, on Friday, the 29th of last month. I stood in the queue for 2 hours and a half.”

“In the queue?”

“In the queue. It seemed to me the only place from which anything could be learned.”

“Before that day, in 11 years, had you ever examined the receipts given to your tenants?”

“No.”

“Had you ever compared the sums actually paid with the sums you were told were due?”

“No.”

“Had you ever asked your agent a single question about the figures he sent you?”

“No.”

“Your Grace,” said Mr. Craig, spreading his hands, “I put it to you that the whole of this unhappy business was made possible by your own neglect.”

“That is correct,” said the Duke of Merestead.

The court made a noise. The judge put his pen down.

“You admit it?”

“Entirely. You may have it in whatever words you like best and I will not quarrel with the words. A man who signs what he has not read has consented to whatever is done with it. I am the only person in this room who could have stopped this in the first quarter of the first year and I did not do it. And I was not prevented by any difficulty except my own convenience.”

Mr. Craig, who had come 140 miles to drag that admission out of a nobleman inch by inch over an afternoon, stood for a moment like a man who has put his whole weight against a door and found it open.

“Then let us speak of Fettle Street,” he said.

“Let us.”

“In the autumn of the 11th year past, a surveyor’s report upon the houses in Fettle Street came into your hands.”

“It came in a packet with 41 other papers on the morning of the 9th of October. I had been in possession of the estate 5 months. My brother had been dead 5 months. I signed the whole packet between 9:00 and a quarter past 10:00 and I read the headings and I did not read the bodies and the report said that the staircase of number nine was sound and it was not sound. And on the 19th of March following it came away from the wall.”

He had not once looked at the jury. He looked at Mr. Craig because Mr. Craig had asked.

“It killed Peg Halloran, who was 31. It killed Mary Halloran, who was five. It killed Thomas Halloran, who was two. I have had those three names written on a card in my pocketbook for 11 years and there is to be a stone put into the wall of the new house with the three of them upon it and the money for the stone is not the estate’s. It is out of my own pocket. Because the estate killed them and I will not have the estate pay for the apology.”