A man might walk in off Pie Row between the barrels, cross 20 ft of cobble, and put his hand on the latch of a shed containing four cases of type, a hand press, and a woman, and no one would be any the wiser until he was inside. He did not go in. He stood against the wall by the window with his arms folded and looked at the drain in the corner of the yard, which was blocked, and at the wall above the drain, which was black to the height of a man’s chest and bulging in two places. And at the gutter that came off the warehouse roof and ended 4 ft short of anything, so that 9 years of rain had been emptying itself at the foot of that wall at the rate of a bucket a minute whenever the weather turned. The wall she had been fined £2 for.

“You are early,” she said behind him.

“The gutter is short.”

“I beg your pardon?”

“The gutter.”

He pointed.

“It should carry to the drain. It stops there. It has stopped there a long time. Look at the mortar. It is washed out to the depth of my thumb.”

“The water comes down inside the wall and freezes and lifts the brick. That is why the wall is bulging. The wall is bulging because nobody has spent four shillings on a length of lead in 9 years.”

Selda Lidbury came and stood beside him and looked up at the end of the gutter as though she had never seen it before, which, he thought, she very likely had not, in the way that nobody ever sees the thing above their own head that has been wrong since before they came.

“£2,” she said.

“£2 for a fault that is his to mend and not yours to answer for by the terms of any lease on this ground that I have ever…”

He stopped himself an instant too late.

“That I have ever heard of. The landlord carries the roof, the gutters, the drains, and the main walls. The tenant carries the glass, the grates, and the plaster. You have been fined for the landlord’s gutter.”

She was looking at him now and not at the wall.

“Mr. Rook,” she said. “What were you before you were a man in a chop house?”

“A man who read papers.”

“For who?”

“For somebody who was robbed,” said the Duke, “and did not find out for 9 years.”

“Did he get his money back?”

“He is not interested in the money.”

“Then he is the only man in England who is not,” she said, and turned away and called into the shed:

“Jem Hollis, if you sing that line once more, I shall have you bound over.”

A boy’s face appeared at the window grinning with a black thumbprint on his forehead like a man on Ash Wednesday.

“This is Mr. Rook. He walks me home. Do not speak to him. He will not answer.”

“Evening, Mr. Rook,” said Jem.