The Duke of Merestead stood up and went to the window and opened the shutter, and down the hill the roofs of eleven streets were coming up out of the dark, and in Fettle Street there was a gap up in the terrace with three courses of brick in it.

“Then let it be printed,” he said.

They took Hesper Dunnage at 20 minutes past 7:00 in the morning at his house in the Crescent, in his dressing gown, with his coffee poured. On his ring there were nine keys, and the fourth of them opened the warehouse door of the Lidbury Press. And the ninth opened a drawer in the writing table in his back parlor, and in the drawer was the thing that hanged him, his own private book, ruled and totted in the same beautiful hand, in which the real rents of 411 doors were set down week by week for nine years against the sums rendered to Merestead, with the difference carried out in a third column and a running total at the foot of every page. The total at the foot of the last page was 11,406 pounds, nine shillings and fourpence.

“They always keep it,” said Mr. Pelham, almost gently turning the leaves. “They must. A man cannot steal for nine years and not know what he has got. It is the vanity of it.”

“He wanted to be able to look at the number.”

“He has bought a farm at Nether Hask,” said Garolin from the other papers. “In his wife’s name.”

“412 acres, and there is a mortgage on a warehouse in Leeds and two shares in the gas company.”

“Mrs. Dunnage,” said the Duke.

“Your Grace…”

“Mrs. Dunnage will be told by Pelham today in her own parlor with another woman present, and she will be told civilly. Whatever is found to be hers is hers. Whatever is not hers is the tenants, and she will not be left with nothing. And if I hear that anybody in this town has put a stone through her window, I shall take it as personally as if it had been through mine. She did not keep that book.”

Pelham looked at him over his spectacles for a moment and then wrote it down. The committal was that afternoon before the bench at the Guildhall, and it lasted 2 hours and 20 minutes. And the Duke of Merestead sat on a bench in the body of the court with his hat on his knees among the tenants of his own ground and was stared at by every soul in Carrogate who could get in at the door. Thirkell Mabb was examined and was sick afterwards in the passage.

Ali Stint, finding himself charged with the assault on a Duke, developed a memory of great richness and detail and gave up his master entire within the half hour. Dunnage was committed to the assizes at the county town for trial on three counts of embezzlement and one of conspiracy, and bail was refused. And as they took him down, he turned and looked at the bench where the Duke was sitting and said perfectly distinctly,