When she reached the line about the duke not knowing, heads turned toward the front pew. And when she had finished, the Duke of Ravensmore stood up beside her.

“Everything in that letter is true,” he said. “And one thing more. Miss Marsh did not trap me into anything. I made a declaration on these steps without asking her, and that was my fault, not hers. She is free of it. Anyone in this parish who wishes to say otherwise may say it to me.”

Nobody did. Mrs. Penhallow, to the astonishment of everyone, began to clap and then stopped, remembering she was in church. The village forgave Lydia within the week. Villages generally forgive quickly once they have been told whom to blame instead. What happened next was harder to forgive because it was nobody’s fault but Gabriel’s.

The new schoolmaster, Mr. Ellery, was young and kind and had a great many opinions about poetry, and he began to call at the vicarage on Tuesday afternoons. And on Tuesday afternoons, by a series of remarkable coincidences, the Duke of Ravensmore began to call too. He came to discuss the church roof. He came to discuss the parish accounts. He came on one memorable occasion to discuss a crack in the font that nobody else could see.

On the fourth Tuesday, Lydia followed him out into the churchyard and stopped him beneath the yew trees.

“You keep deciding,” she said, “who may stand near me.”

“I do nothing of the kind.”

“You came to discuss the font.”

“The font is cracked.”

“The font has been cracked since the reign of Queen Anne. Mr. Ellery is a kind man who likes Wordsworth, and every time he opens his mouth, you appear in the doorway like a thunderstorm.”

Gabriel’s jaw tightened.

“Mr. Ellery wants—”

“What?” Lydia demanded. “What does he want, Your Grace? And why should it be for you to decide whether he may have it?”

He said nothing. It was the wrong kind of nothing. And Lydia, who had been born with a bell, rang it once too hard.

“You promised me in Scotland that I was free,” she said. “You stood up in church and said it, and now you behave exactly like every man who has ever decided things for a woman and called it care. You are no different from Lord Halvering.”

The moment she said it, she knew it was cruel. She watched it reach him. She watched something in his face close quietly, like a door in a house at night.

“Then I will stop,” he said.

He bowed correctly and walked away through the lychgate. He did not look back. Lydia lay awake that night for the third time in a month, and this time she could not blame Lady Cecily or Lady Honoria or anyone else. She thought of a man who counted the exits in every room, a man who had stood between a frightened girl and her father without being asked, a man who had ridden three hundred miles to tell her she owed him nothing, and agreed to every one of her conditions before she had finished naming them, and told a doctor in Kendal that the horses were restless in their sleep.

He had not been deciding things for her. He had been standing in doorways because he did not know how to say what he wanted, and the only thing he had ever been taught to do with a thing he wanted was guard it. Lydia sat up in bed and put both hands over her face.