“I was wondering,” she said, “whether you had asked her.”

“Asked her what?”

“Anything at all.”

Gabriel went very still. Behind him, the side door creaked as someone passed through it.

“Lady Cecily has consented,” he said.

“Has she?” Miss Marsh’s voice was quiet. “Or has someone consented on her behalf, and she has simply stopped arguing?”

It was an outrageous thing to say to a duke three days before his wedding. It was an outrageous thing to say to anyone. He waited for the anger to come and found instead something colder and less comfortable: a small question that had been sitting in the corner of his mind for weeks, waiting for someone else to say it first.

“In the army, Miss Marsh,” he said slowly, “I learned that silence is how good men die politely. They see the problem. They assume someone more important has seen it too, and they say nothing because it is not their place.”

She looked up at him. Her eyes were gray and very steady.

“Then perhaps you will understand me better than you expect, Your Grace.”

“Gabriel!” His aunt’s voice rang from the west door. “The carriage.”

He bowed and went. He did not see Mrs. Penhallow, the butcher’s widow and the most reliable source of news in three parishes, standing just inside the side door with a basket of eggs over her arm, having watched the Duke of Ravensmore and the vicar’s sister speak alone in low voices beside the font for three full minutes. Mrs. Penhallow did not know what had been said. This had never once prevented her from repeating it.

Lydia did not sleep on Saturday night. She lay in her narrow bed under the eaves and listened to the vicarage settle around her. She told herself that it was not her affair. She told herself that brides were frightened all the time, that Lady Cecily might wake on Sunday morning calm and resigned, that a girl of nineteen could not possibly know her own heart. She told herself that Thomas would lose his living, that they would be sent to Cumberland, that she would spend the rest of her life explaining to sheep why she had ruined everything.

None of it worked. Every time she closed her eyes, she saw a girl looking at a long stone aisle the way a soldier looks at a field. At five, she rose and dressed in her best gown, which was the same faded blue as her second-best gown, only with fewer darns. At ten, she took her place in the third pew. The Church of St. Margaret had never held so many people.

They pressed shoulder to shoulder in the pews and stood three deep along the walls. Ladies fanned themselves, although the morning was cool. Gentlemen checked their watches, although nobody intended to leave. In the front pew on the right sat the Earl of Halvering, broad and red and satisfied, like a man who has sold a horse for more than it was worth. In the front pew on the left sat Lady Honoria Strath, upright as a candlestick, wearing an expression that suggested she had personally arranged the weather.

And at the altar, in a dark blue coat with a single medal he had clearly been ordered to wear, stood the Duke of Ravensmore. Lydia looked at him and wished quite suddenly that he were a worse man. It would have been so much simpler. But he was standing very straight with his hands behind his back, and his eyes kept moving to the doors. One, two, three, as though some part of him were still waiting for something to come through them.