If he had learned anything in seven years of war, it was that retreating from a field too quickly told the enemy everything they wanted to know. So three hundred people ate lobster patties and iced cake beneath the painted ceilings of Ravensmore Hall and stared at the vicar’s sister, who sat at the duke’s right hand and ate nothing at all. Gabriel watched her across the course of that long, terrible afternoon. She held her fork correctly. She answered when spoken to.

She did not smile once. When the Earl of Halvering’s cousin made a remark about country girls who knew how to seize an opportunity, she turned and looked at him with such cool, level gray eyes that the man choked on his wine and had to be patted on the back. It was only later, when the last carriage had gone and the house had fallen quiet, that Gabriel allowed himself to think. He stood at the window of his study with a glass of brandy he did not want, and he did what he had always done after a battle. He went over the ground.

She had spoken to him on Thursday, alone beside the font. She had told him, in effect, that his bride did not want him. She had then stood up in church and proved it before three hundred witnesses. And by the end of the day, she was engaged to a duke. Laid out like that, it looked very much like a campaign.

He had seen clever officers win battles that way. Find the weakness. Wait for the moment. Strike once, cleanly, in front of everyone, so that the other side has no choice but to surrender on your terms. He did not want to believe it.

That was exactly why he made himself consider it. And yet she had said, “I object,” quietly to him alone, where it would win her nothing. A woman playing for a coronet did not object when she had just been handed one, unless, of course, she was clever enough to know that a little reluctance made a prize look more honestly won. Gabriel set down the brandy, untouched. He thought of her face in the churchyard when the girl of twelve had looked away.

He thought of the way she had said, “It was hers to tell.” He thought of her hand in his, cold as stone, and how it had not once tightened, not in triumph and not in relief. Either she was the most honest woman in the county, or the most dangerous. He would know which, he decided, when he went to the vicarage on Tuesday and asked her properly, the way he should have asked in the first place. He did not know, standing at that window, that his aunt had already ordered her carriage.

Lady Honoria Strath arrived at the vicarage at nine that same evening, without warning, in a black traveling cloak with the hood thrown back. Thomas opened the door himself because the maid had gone home. He looked at Lady Honoria the way a man looks at a letter he already knows contains bad news.

“Mr. Marsh,” she said, “I will not keep you long. I find long visits are seldom necessary when the facts are clear.”

She was shown into the small parlor. She did not sit. Lydia stood by the cold fireplace and did not sit either, which made three of them standing in a room built for people who preferred to sit down and be comfortable.

“I will be brief,” said Lady Honoria. “My nephew has made a public declaration this afternoon. It was generous of him. It was also a mistake. Gabriel has always confused honor with impulse, and it has cost the family a great deal over the years.”