So she sat beside Lady Cecily, handed her a handkerchief that smelled faintly of lily pollen, and waited. The church was very quiet. Somewhere above them, a pigeon shifted in the bell tower.
“I don’t love him,” Lady Cecily whispered at last.
Lydia said nothing. A great many brides did not love their grooms. Most of them married anyway, and some of them learned to, and some of them learned to pretend.
“You don’t understand,” Cecily said. “I love someone else. His name is James Carrow. He was a lieutenant. He came home from the war with a cough and no fortune and a medal he keeps in a drawer because he says it embarrasses him.” She twisted the handkerchief. “We were going to marry. He wrote to my father. My father burned the letter in front of me and told me that girls who refuse dukes are sent to their grandmothers in Northumberland and are never heard from again.”
“Does the duke know?” Lydia asked.
Cecily laughed, a terrible little sound.
“Nobody asks the duke anything, Miss Marsh. His aunt arranged it while he was still in France. My father arranged me. Nobody asks either of us. They only tell us both.”
“Then tell him yourself.”
“I can’t.” Cecily’s eyes were wide and wet. “If I shame my father, he will ruin James. He has friends at the War Office. He has friends everywhere. And James is waiting by the old mill every evening, as if I could simply walk out of my father’s house and come to him.” She pressed the handkerchief to her mouth. “Promise me you won’t say anything. Promise me.”
Lydia looked at her for a long moment. She thought of the aisle. She thought of a girl walking down it toward a man she did not want, while her father watched from the front pew to make sure she did not stop.
“I am very sorry,” Lydia said gently, “but I have never been able to make that particular promise. I would only break it, and then you would have two people to be disappointed in.”
Lady Cecily stared at her. Then, unexpectedly, she laughed again, and this time it was almost real.
“You are very strange, Miss Marsh.”
“So I have been told, usually by my brother.”
When Lady Cecily had gone, Lydia finished the lilies with hands that were not quite steady. That evening, over cold mutton and a sermon Thomas was trying to shorten, she told him everything. Thomas Marsh was four years older than his sister, thin and earnest, with ink on his fingers and worry permanently folded into his forehead. He listened without interrupting. When she finished, he put down his pen.
“Lydia,” he said carefully, “you do understand who holds the living of this parish.”
“The Ravensmore family.”
“Lady Honoria Strath, specifically. The duke’s aunt. She chose me herself out of six candidates because I preach short sermons and do not argue.” He rubbed his eyes. “One wrong word from this house and we will be preaching to sheep in Cumberland for the rest of our lives.”
“Sheep would be better listeners,” said Lydia.
“Lydia.”
“I haven’t said anything, Thomas.”
“You have that face.”
“What face?”
“The face you had when you were nine years old and told the bishop his wig was crooked in front of the whole congregation.”
“It was crooked.”
“Everyone knew it was crooked,” said Thomas. “That is precisely why nobody said so.” He picked up his pen again and looked at her over it. “Promise me you will let this alone.”