“I did not ask him to declare anything,” said Lydia.
“No, you merely stood up in church and made it impossible for him to do otherwise.” Lady Honoria regarded her without warmth. “Whether you intended it or not is of no interest to me. I am interested in what happens next.”
“And what happens next, my lady?” asked Thomas.
“On Sunday at morning service, Miss Marsh will stand in the same church and make a second announcement. She will thank the duke for his kindness and decline his offer. She will then leave the county. I have a cousin in Bath who requires a companion. The position is respectable and quite distant.”
Thomas went white.
“And if she does not?”
Lady Honoria looked around the parlor, at the threadbare carpet, at the shelf of sermons, at the window through which the dark shape of the church could be seen against the sky.
“The living of St. Margaret’s is in the gift of my family, Mr. Marsh. I chose you. I can choose again. There are excellent parishes in the north of Cumberland that have been without a vicar for some years. The air is very bracing.”
The clock on the mantel ticked.
“You knew,” said Lydia.
Lady Honoria turned her head.
“You knew Lady Cecily was unwilling,” Lydia said. “You must have known. You arranged everything. You told the duke she was delighted. Positively delighted.”
For a moment, something flickered across Lady Honoria’s face. It might have been irritation. It might have been the faint, distant ghost of shame.
“Willingness, Miss Marsh,” she said, “is a luxury for people who have nothing to protect. Lady Cecily would have been grateful in a year. Most women are.” She drew on her gloves. “You have until Sunday.”
She left the way she had come, without hurry and without raising her voice. The sound of her carriage faded into the night. Thomas and Lydia stood in the parlor and listened to it go. Then Thomas sat down very heavily in his chair and put his face in his hands.
“Thomas,” Lydia began.
“Don’t.” His voice was muffled. “Please, Lydia. Not tonight.”
“I could not let that girl—”
“I know.” He lifted his head. His eyes were red. “I know you couldn’t. You never can. You always speak, and I always pay for it.”
He heard the words as he said them, and his face changed instantly, crumpling with regret.
“Lydia, I didn’t mean—”
“Yes, you did,” she said gently. “And you’re right.”
She went upstairs before he could see her cry. She did not sleep that night either. She sat at her small table under the eaves with a candle and a sheet of paper and thought harder than she had ever thought in her life. If she refused the duke on Sunday, as Lady Honoria demanded, the village would decide she had been rejected. The scandal would follow her to Bath and to every place after Bath for the rest of her life.
And Lady Honoria might keep her word about Thomas, or she might not. Women like Lady Honoria kept their promises only when it was convenient. If she accepted the duke, she would be marrying a man who had not asked her, out of pity and obligation, and she would spend her life watching him wonder whether she had trapped him. She had seen that question in his face at the breakfast table. She had seen him weighing her.
There was only one thing that could clear her name, and Thomas’s with it, and the duke’s. The truth, written down in the hand of the only person who could tell it: Lady Cecily Dunmore. Lydia did not know where Cecily had gone, but she knew which way the gray horse had turned at the end of the village street. North. And she knew, as every girl in England knew from the novels she was not supposed to read, where young couples went when they rode north in a hurry with no time for banns.