Neither of them thought about the watch that night, and neither was awake at seven the next morning when a chimney sweep with a cart full of brushes knocked at the back door of Caro Park.
He had a note. It said that the steward, Mr. Dewhurst, had arranged for him to sweep the study chimney before the cold weather came. Pinchbeck looked at the note. He looked at the sweep, a small, thin man with a soot-black face and a cap pulled low.
Mr. Dewhurst was away on estate business until Saturday, but it was his handwriting, and the study chimney did smoke. Pinchbeck let the sweep in. He spread dust sheets over the carpet. Pinchbeck left him alone in the study for about four minutes while he went to fetch more sheets from the linen cupboard. When he returned, the sweep was busy with his long rods, humming softly. By half past seven he was gone.
The Duke had ridden out before dawn on private business toward Towcester. He returned at ten, muddy to his eyebrows, carrying a small paper packet in his pocket. He went straight to his study, unlocked the desk drawer, and took out the green velvet case without opening it. He did not want to open it. Not yet. Not without her.
By eleven o’clock the back room of the Caro Arms was packed. Half the estate had come. People stood on benches, sat on barrels, and leaned in through the open windows. Sir Hector Bellamy sat at a long table with an inkpot and a very large handkerchief in his pocket. Barnaby Coyle sat to one side, his two hired men behind him. Alone on the other side sat Prudence Tolliver, wearing her one good gray gown and holding her little roll of tools.
The Duke arrived last. He did not take a seat at the front with the gentry. He went to the back of the room and stood beside Prudence’s chair, his hands clasped behind him. He said nothing. She did not look up, but she shifted a little closer to him.
Sir Hector began.
“Mr. Coyle claims the watch is his security, pledged in February. Miss Tolliver claims it is a commission for His Grace, completed in August. Let us begin with the watch itself. Your Grace?”
The Duke placed the green velvet case on the table. Pinchbeck stood stiffly at the door, ready to confirm that the case had been locked in the desk all night. Sir Hector opened it and turned it so everyone in the room could see. There it lay on faded green velvet, gold with a white dial and roses around the case.
Prudence leaned forward to look, and the color drained from her face.
“Miss Tolliver?” Sir Hector said.
She did not answer immediately. She reached out and picked up the watch. She weighed it in her palm. She put it to her ear and listened with her eyes shut for about five seconds. Then she set it down and looked up at the magistrate.
“That is not my watch,” Prudence Tolliver said.
The room erupted. Farmers shouted. Someone’s dog began barking beneath a table. Sir Hector banged the inkpot against the wood until ink splashed. Barnaby Coyle jumped to his feet, beaming like a man who had just won a horse race.
“She admits it!” he cried. “Everyone heard her! She admits it. She made His Grace a cheap imitation and called it gold. And I shall tell you why, Sir Hector.”
He reached dramatically inside his coat.
“Because the real watch, my watch, was never hers to give away.”