He produced a second green leather case and opened it on the table. On cream silk lay a gold watch with a white face and a border of climbing roses. The room fell silent.

“My man purchased it at first light this morning,” Coyle said smoothly. “From a dealer in Northampton. A young woman sold it to him on Wednesday. I need hardly say which young woman. She intended to sell my watch, keep the money, and give His Grace a worthless copy. The marriage was a falsehood. The watch is a falsehood. All of it is lies.”

Every head turned toward Prudence. She sat very straight in her chair, her hands folded on the little tool roll. She looked first at the second watch and then slowly across the room to where Pinchbeck stood by the door.

The butler stiffened. He was the only other person with a key. Everyone knew that. He had been cold to her from the moment she entered the hall. Pinchbeck’s face went pale, but he said nothing.

Beside her chair, the Duke stood perfectly still. He said nothing. He did not touch her. He simply stayed.

Prudence took a deep breath.

“Sir Hector,” she said, “may I use my tools to examine both watches in front of everyone?”

Sir Hector looked at Coyle. Coyle shrugged and smiled.

“Let her. It makes no difference.”

“Then proceed, miss,” Sir Hector said.

Prudence unrolled her tools and spread them across the table: a folding magnifying glass, a thin steel case knife with a flat blade. She picked up the first watch, the one that had been in the Duke’s desk.

“This watch is an imitation,” she said. “Quite a good imitation at first sight, but it weighs about two-thirds as much as the real one. The case is not gold. It is pinchbeck.”

By the door, the butler made a small, pained sound.

“I beg your pardon, Mr. Pinchbeck,” Prudence said without looking up. “It is a metal, copper and zinc. A London watchmaker invented it a hundred years ago to look like gold. It is perfectly honest when sold for what it is. This one was not.”

She slipped the steel blade into the rim and opened the back.

“The movement is Dutch. Cheap. You can tell by the little brass bridge over the balance. It is cut in the shape of a fat little cherub. Dutch makers were very fond of cherubs. And listen.”

She held it up for the room. It ticked quickly and unevenly. Tick, tick. Tick, tick.

“It limps,” Prudence said. “Out of beat. My watch uses a lever escapement. It ticks like a heartbeat. This one runs like a man with one leg.”

She tilted the open case into the window light and peered inside through her glass.

“And here is another thing.”

She turned the open case toward Sir Hector.

“Do you see these scratches inside the lid, sir? A number scratched with a needle. Two, two, one, four, and a little crescent moon beside it.”

Sir Hector squinted.

“I do.”

“That is a pawnbroker’s mark,” Prudence said. “Every London pawnbroker scratches a pledge number inside the case of a watch. That way, if the ticket is lost, they still know which watch belongs to which pledge. Each shop has its own little mark. This one is a crescent moon.”

She looked up.

“Mr. Coyle, what is painted on the sign above your shop in Cowcross Street?”

Coyle said nothing.

“I have passed it every week of my life,” Prudence continued. “It has three gold balls, like every pawnbroker’s shop, and beneath them a silver crescent moon.”