This one had been freshly printed. The ink was not quite dry. In neat, small letters it read:

Repaired by P. Tolliver, 1818.

To be kept by R. Lyle forever. Will you let him keep you, too?

“I woke the printer in Towcester at five this morning,” the Duke said. “He was not pleased. I paid him double. He spelled Tolliver wrong twice before he got it right.”

Prudence stared at the little paper for a long time. Her eyes filled. She blinked hard.

“You are a dreadful liar, Your Grace. You do know that?”

“I have only ever told one. And things have gone badly since Tuesday.”

“I said this morning,” she said. “You said Tuesday. We were both right.”

He knelt beside her chair in the back room of the Caro Arms, in front of what seemed to be half of Northamptonshire.

“Prue,” he said, “I do not want you to pretend anymore. I want it to be true. I want you to repair every clock in this county, scold me whenever I am late, and never repair my own watch, because those four minutes are mine. They are four minutes I have to look at you before I must go anywhere.”

There was a long, rather damp silence.

“You will need adjusting,” Prudence said, her voice trembling. “Frequently. For the rest of your life.”

“I was counting on it.”

From the front of the room came a sharp, triumphant voice. Lady Augusta stood on a bench while the vicar held her skirts out of the way.

“Well?” she demanded. “Don’t just kneel there, Robert. What am I to tell the parson?”

Prudence laughed. It was the same big, surprised laugh that had startled the crows out of the hedge.

“Tell him I’m your wife,” she said.

The Duke smiled at her.

“Not yet.”

Then Prudence Tolliver said, “Tell him I will be.”

They were married on December 23, 1818, in the little church at Caro. Snow fell all morning. Mr. Pinchbeck walked the bride down the aisle, for she had no father to do it, and he did not faint even once. Mr. and Mrs. Amory traveled all the way from Little Wotton. They reported that the church clock there had not lost a minute since August.

Lady Augusta cheated at whist during the wedding festivities. Sir Hector caught her twice and pretended not to notice. The judge at the Northampton Assizes sent Barnaby Coyle a very long way away, to the other side of the world, as people used to say in those days. He never troubled anyone in Clerkenwell again.

Thrip told the whole truth at the trial. In the spring he returned to Caro Park to work under the head gardener. He was never asked to go near a chimney again, and he never volunteered.

The little shop in St. John Street reopened that spring. The sign over the door read “Tolliver and Lyle, Watchmakers.” It was run by a young craftsman whom Prudence trained herself.

At Caro she kept her father’s old workbench in a round room at the top of the East Tower. By the end of her first year she had repaired every clock in the house, every clock in the village, and most of the clocks in the county.

The gold repeating watch stood on the table by the drawing-room window, where the Duke’s mother used to sit before dawn. Every morning, before anyone lit a candle, the Duchess of Caro pressed its pendant, and the watch softly told the hour in the dark.

Seven years later, on a bright April morning in 1825, the Duke climbed the tower stairs and found his wife sitting at her workbench. Their daughter Amy, now six, had completely dismantled the nursery clock and spread its pieces across the floor. Their son Tom, now four, was handing his mother each screw in turn and saying:

“This is important. That is important.”

“Amy,” the Duke said, “what did we say about the nursery clock?”

“It’s mine,” Amy said, “and I can do anything I like with it because Mama said I could.”

The Duke looked at his wife. His wife looked innocently out of the window. He took out his father’s old silver watch and opened it. Inside the case, the small round watch paper had faded a little, but the words were still there: To be kept by R. Lyle forever.

“Still four minutes slow,” he said.

“I know,” Prudence said.

She smiled at him over the heap of tiny brass wheels.

“Some things are perfectly right just as they are. A little slow, perhaps, but never stopping.”

He bent and kissed her in the middle of all the screws. Outside, far below, the clock in the stable tower began to strike. And four minutes later, by his father’s watch, the Duke of Caro agreed.