The Duke looked at Prudence. Her face was smudged with rust and pigeon dust. Her hair was coming loose. She was grinning like a girl. He thought she was the most beautiful woman he had ever seen.

That evening Mrs. Amory gave them the spare room. It contained one narrow bed, a washstand, and a rag rug.

“For Mr. and Mrs. Lyle,” she said kindly, “with our thanks.”

This time there was no chair at all. The Duke lay down on the rag rug, using his coat for a pillow and a horse blanket over his legs. For a long while there was only the rain.

Then, in the darkness, Prudence said, “Mr. Lyle?”

“Yes?”

“Thank you for holding the light.”

“I would hold it again any time,” he said.

A long silence followed.

“Tell me about the Duke,” she said. “The real Duke. Not the gout. What is he like?”

The Duke lay still on the rug and stared at the dark ceiling.

“He loved his mother very much,” he said at last. “She used to wake before dawn and sit by the window reading. She would never light a candle because she said it wasted the darkness. When he was a boy, he used to creep in and sit at her feet. She would ask him what time he thought it was, and he would guess, and she would laugh and tell him he was wrong, as usual.”

He stopped.

“She liked roses. Climbing roses. The pink ones that grow on old walls.”

Prudence was quiet for a long time.

“The engraving on the case,” she said softly. “The roses around it and the large rose at the bottom. My father drew that design in 1812. The steward’s letter said the lady loved climbing roses.”

“Yes,” the Duke said. “She did.”

“There is something else inside the watch,” Prudence said, “something the steward sent us. A secret. I cannot tell you what it is. I promised I would show it only to the Duke.”

His heart gave one heavy, painful beat. He had forgotten. He had truly forgotten. Six years earlier, in his grief, he had sent something to Clerkenwell with that letter. Since then he had not allowed himself to remember it.

“Prue,” he said.

It was the first time he had called her that.

“There is something I must tell you.”

But the only answer from the narrow bed was a small, gentle snore like a tiny kettle. He lay awake on the rag rug until the church clock, her clock, struck two. Tomorrow, he decided. At Caro he would tell her everything before she set foot through the door. He planned it, word by word.

What he had not planned was that Barnaby Coyle would arrive first.

Caro Park rose out of the November fields like a scene from a painting. The house was built of pale yellow stone, three stories high, with long rows of windows catching the weak sunlight. Prudence found herself counting them. There were so many windows.

“Good heavens,” she said. “How many are there?”

“One hundred and twelve,” the Duke answered before he could stop himself.

She turned and stared at him.

“I’ve cleaned a few,” he added quickly. “As steward, one hears about them constantly.”

The long drive was busy with farm carts, ponies, and people wearing their Sunday best. Smoke rose from the kitchen chimneys. Somewhere a fiddle was playing.

“It’s the tenants’ dinner,” the Duke said. “Every year in the second week of November. The whole estate comes to the house for roast beef and plum pudding.”

“Then the Duke will be busy,” Prudence said.