Alistair waved a tired hand, for he had no patience left for petitioners. Edmund lingered and added a strange detail. The woman had spoken of the Western Wool Warehouse, a building that had not appeared in any report of the estate for years, and she had named it correctly. Alistair lifted his head. Nobody outside the family and its oldest servants remembered that crumbling storehouse, and the account books never mentioned it.

“Bring her in,” he said.

The door opened on a rush of cold air, and a woman in a faded cloak stepped inside, a leather satchel clutched in her hands. Her chestnut hair was pinned tightly. Her green eyes were tired but steady, and she did not curtsy like a supplicant.

“Your Grace, I have not come to ask for money,” she said. “I have come because you are being asked to pay a debt that is not what you have been told.”

The woman gave her name as Mabel Whitcomb, widow of Thomas Whitcomb, who had managed warehouses and freight wagons across the north of Yorkshire. Her brown wool dress had been mended so many times that the stitches formed a pattern of their own, and beside the portraits of dukes and the carved oak furniture, she looked like a sparrow in a cathedral. Alistair noticed none of this for long, because she was already laying papers on his desk with the economy of someone who knew exactly where each sheet belonged. Behind them, the door opened again, and Lord Blackthorn returned to retrieve a document he had forgotten. He stopped, studied the visitor from her boots to her bonnet, and an expression of mild disgust crossed his face.

When Mabel said she could propose a way to settle the duke’s debt, Percival laughed aloud.

“A widow who lives on market arithmetic now proposes to teach a duke how to run his estate?” he asked, turning to Alistair as if inviting him into the joke.

Mabel did not rise to it. She asked the duke three questions in an even voice.

“How many storehouses on the estate are still fit for use? How many freight shipments have been moved to other carriers in the past year? And why has the cost of storing wool risen while the amount of wool stored has fallen?”

Alistair opened his mouth and found that he did not know. He had always left such matters to others, and the others had always told him that everything was in order. Percival waved the questions away as the concerns of hired clerks.

“The small things that nobody wants to examine,” Mabel said quietly, “are exactly what produced the large debts.”

The words landed in the room like a dropped coin, and for a moment even the fire seemed to listen. While the argument went on, Alistair watched the widow more carefully than he had watched anyone in months. She stood with her hands folded, her back straight, absorbing Percival’s mockery the way a seawall absorbs the tide without moving and without pretense. He had met many men who spoke loudly about money and few who could explain where it went. It irritated him that the first person to ask the right questions had been turned away twice at his own gate.

And beneath the irritation was something less comfortable, a suspicion that he had spent years surrounded by people whose only qualification was a respectable surname. Half testing her and half hoping to be proven wrong, Alistair pushed the most recent quarterly report across the desk. Mabel read it in a few minutes, her finger moving down the columns. She pointed out two payments that carried the same freight code yet were recorded under two different headings. She did not call it fraud and she did not raise her voice.