She simply worked later into the night and Beatrice Fenwick passing the library door left a cup of tea at her elbow without saying a word. It was the first kindness anyone in that house had offered her that was not required by courtesy. Percival learned that Mabel was examining the contracts and he struck swiftly. He wrote to the wool merchants of Leeds hinting that Ravenshollow was close to insolvency and that any deposit paid there might vanish. Two of the merchants withdrew from the negotiations within the week.
Whispers followed through the district that the duke had put his fortunes in the hands of a widow who was making matters worse. Hugh Telford came to Alistair pale and shaking and urged him to end her contract before the damage grew. Alistair was angry and the anger was real. Their only hope was beginning to crumble and he demanded to know why Mabel had not told him at once that her late husband had been connected to the freight network. Mabel admitted she had suspected something was wrong.
She had not wished to present a theory as a fact before she had evidence.
“Your Grace, you hired me for my ability to check what others tell you,” she said. “Then please check what I tell you as well.”
The words steadied him more than any apology could have. He did not choose blind faith and he did not choose panic. Instead, he asked Pritchard to verify every piece of evidence independently, to separate honest accounting errors from legitimate transactions and from signs of deceit. He refused Hugh’s request to dismiss Mabel, telling the bookkeeper that he would not discard the only person who had found the truth merely because the truth was inconvenient. It was a small decision, but it was the first time he had ever acted against both fear and fashion at the same moment.
A few days later, the solicitor found something in a bundle of old papers, a supplementary record that had been misfiled years before. It could establish who was ultimately responsible for a sum that Ravenshollow had paid long ago and that now seemed to be demanded a second time. The note referred to an original receipt held in the counting house of a merchant in Leeds. Pritchard’s eyes lit with the rare excitement of a lawyer who has found his proof. The warehouse of the merchant stood two days away across snow-choked roads.
Then Edmund brought word from a friend in Leeds that made the Duke’s stomach tighten. An agent acting for Lord Blackthorn had already called at that very counting house and he had gone in asking for old receipts. If the paper disappeared, the case would rest on memory and memory was no match for a baron’s reputation. Alistair stood, called for his coat and said that he would go himself. They left before sunrise, Alistair, Mabel and Mr. Pritchard crowded into the Duke’s old coach while the horses blew steam into the dark.
The journey to Leeds was meant to recover a document, but it had a second purpose as well. Wilfred Baines, a wool merchant who had once dealt with the Whitcomb family, might sign a storage contract with Ravenshollow if he could be convinced of its reliability. The snow lay heavy on the moors and in places the road vanished entirely beneath drifts that the wind had piled against the stone walls. Hour after hour the coach rocked and groaned and the passengers spoke little. Somewhere past noon Alistair asked Mabel why she bore the insults of men like Percival and did not simply leave.