Percival’s accusation had cleverly blurred two very different kinds of responsibility into one. Alistair then opened the envelope Mabel had left beside her note, and inside he found her final reconciliation, every figure laid out in her neat hand. He read it standing by the cold window, and slowly a different and darker truth emerged from the columns. If the numbers were confirmed, Percival had not merely exaggerated the duke’s difficulties, he had been steering Alistair towards selling the very assets that could pay everything he owed. The creditors’ meeting was held in the great dining hall of Ravenshollow, where a long table had been set beneath portraits of six dead dukes.

Lord Blackthorn sat in the center with the easy confidence of a man who already counted himself the winner. He believed that Alistair had nothing left but to sign, and he had brought the papers prepared. The room smelled of beeswax and wood smoke, and wind pressed against the tall windows. When the door opened, however, the duke did not enter alone. Alistair came in with Pritchard and a leather case of verified documents.

Behind them walked Mabel Whitcomb in her mended brown dress. The Duke had ridden to Hawthorn Beck himself the day before, and he had stood on her doorstep in the cold and asked her to attend as his advisor and as an expert witness. He had told her plainly that he had handled the matter poorly, that he regretted the hurt he had caused, and that she was entirely free to refuse. She had thought it over for a long minute and then agreed, for the work was unfinished and she did not leave unfinished work. Percival saw her and burst into laughter.

“Are we holding a financial meeting or a reading class for widows?” he asked the room.

A few of the creditors smiled uneasily. Alistair walked to the head of the table without haste.

“We are holding a meeting to establish the truth,” he said, “and anyone who holds documents relating to it has the right to present them.”

The smiles vanished and Pritchard rose, opening his case. The solicitor began with the debt itself. He showed that the sum Percival demanded had combined obligations not yet due with surcharges still in dispute. He showed too the certified receipt from Leeds proving that one payment had been made, yet never properly credited to the balance. When the items were separated, the amount that could not be postponed was far smaller than £12,000.

Pritchard was careful, as always, to say that not every debt had vanished. He asked only that the creditors confirm the balances anew and agree to extend those obligations that were fairly extendable. The murmurs around the table changed their tone. Then Alistair spoke of the second matter and his voice was steady. He placed before the creditors a set of conditional contracts that he and Mabel had negotiated with their own hands.

Wilfred Baines and two other merchants had agreed to rent warehouse space, paying their deposits as each building was handed over in proper condition. A portion of the repair cost would be deducted as the work progressed and a commercial advance on goods ready for delivery would supply the remainder. Together these funds would provide enough cash to meet the pressing obligations once the lenders confirmed the balances.

“This is not free money,” Alistair added, looking down the table. “I must deliver on these contracts. The quality of the buildings, the labor, and the freight are mine to answer for.”

He paused.

“But I will not hand my estate to Lord Blackthorn to do it.”