Percival went on and offered her £5 to leave Ravenshollow quietly, observing that it was probably more than she earned in a month. The guests looked into their plates. Mabel laid her napkin beside her plate with perfect calm.
“My lord, I was engaged to solve a financial problem,” she said. “I was not engaged to endure insults.”
Alistair rose from his chair. He told the entire table that Mrs. Whitcomb was his appointed advisor, that she had every right to attend the professional meetings the plan required, and that he expected an apology from Lord Blackthorn. Percival refused with a thin smile. The Duke ended the dinner early and asked his guest to leave. And the carriage wheels crunching away over the frozen gravel were the only sound in the hall.
Later that night, Alistair found Mabel in the library where the candles had burned low and she sat alone with a ledger. He apologized for what she had endured beneath his roof. She answered that she did not need a Duke to defend her against every unkind word. What she needed was for him not to let prejudice decide who was permitted to speak. He looked at her for a long moment and for the first time he understood that the respect growing between them had nothing to do with his title and perhaps never would.
Hours afterwards, searching a box of old papers, Mabel went still. Her fingers had stopped on a copy of a freight contract and at the bottom of it was a signature she knew as well as her own, that of her husband Thomas. The agreement had been made with the very company that later became Percival’s agent. She sat motionless while the candle guttered and Alistair, who had come to say good night, saw her face and stopped in the doorway.
“I have seen this contract before,” she said at last, “but it was under a different name.”
Over the next several days, Lionel Pritchard and Mabel worked side by side at a table in the library, comparing contracts line by line while the winter light came and went. They learned that a freight agent who had once served Ravenshollow had transferred his agreements to another company and that this company traded closely with Lord Blackthorn. The transfer by itself was not illegal and Pritchard was careful to say so more than once. The trouble lay in the surcharges in deliveries recorded without clear descriptions and in the manner in which the payment demands had been announced. It was a pattern that looked random until the pieces were laid together.
Alistair listened to their findings in the study and slowly the picture he had held of Percival began to turn over. He had believed the baron the only man willing to rescue him. Now he saw that someone who profits from a fire might also be the first to arrive with a bucket. Percival might have used the estate’s weakness to gather, one agreement at a time, the very properties that could earn the most. The debts were not only the result of poor management.
Some of the weight had been added by the way the transactions were arranged. For Mabel the discovery was more painful than the duke could know. She had loved her husband and for three years she had carried the quiet fear that his business dealings had left some shadow behind. Now she turned his old letters over in her hands and wondered whether Thomas had been deceived or had trusted the wrong man or had known more than he ever said. She did not weep.