“That one is not ours to share, my lark,” he would say. “It belongs to someone. One day, perhaps, it will go home.”
Anna had never understood what he meant. On the night he died, he had pressed a folded sheet of old music into her hands, yellowed and fragile, written in a delicate slanting hand that was not his own. Across the top, in faded ink, were the words “For my little lark.” And at the bottom, a single letter, “I.”
“Keep it safe,” he had whispered. “Promise me. I tried once to give it back, and they would not let me through the gate. Perhaps you will have better fortune.”
“Give it back to whom, Papa?”
But he had only closed his eyes and smiled, and by morning he was gone. Now the sheet lay at the very bottom of Anna’s trunk, wrapped in a silk handkerchief beneath her shawl, and the tune lived inside her as it always had. And every afternoon, in a house where music was forbidden, she hummed it under her breath to a little girl who did not speak. One afternoon, Philippa lifted her head from her arms and looked at Anna with a question in her gray eyes. She did not need words. Anna understood.
“It is a song for someone who was loved very much,” Anna told her softly. “That is all I know about it. Isn’t that enough?”
Philippa considered this. Then she laid her head back down. At the end of the third week, as Anna hummed, she felt something against her arm. Philippa had lifted her head again, and her lips were moving. She made no sound, but Anna watched that small mouth shape the rise and fall of the melody, and on the strange third note, the child’s lips curved just slightly into the beginning of a smile.
Anna had to look away so that Philippa would not see her eyes fill with tears. The Duke saw his daughter smile 4 days later. Anna did not know he was there. She and Philippa were in the East Garden among the bare rose bushes, and Anna had turned their walk into a game. Every time Philippa spotted a robin, Anna would give her a sugared almond from her pocket.
Philippa had found five robins and a sparrow that she insisted, with great seriousness and a stamp of her small boot, was also a robin. Anna had laughed and given her the almond anyway, and Philippa had smiled, a real smile, wide and gap-toothed and dazzling. When Anna turned, the Duke was standing at the end of the gravel path. He was in his riding coat, his boots splashed with mud, his hat in his hand. He was not looking at Anna.
He was looking at his daughter, and his face wore the expression of a man who has been lost in the dark for a very long time and has suddenly glimpsed a lamp in a window. Then Philippa saw him and the smile vanished. She stepped behind Anna’s skirts. The Duke’s face closed like a door.