“He found her music, every page she’d ever written. He burned it in the grate of the gold drawing room, sheet by sheet, while she stood and watched, and he made the boy watch, too. He said it would teach him what came of foolishness.”
Her voice shook.
“Her Grace was never the same. She took ill that winter, and she was gone by spring. The boy was 10. The music master was dismissed the very same week because the old duke blamed him for encouraging her. And when Her Grace died, the old duke had the music room bolted and forbade a single note to be played in this house ever again.”
“But the old duke has been dead for years, 12 years.”
Mrs. Bell nodded slowly.
“And still, the room stays bolted. I think, Miss Hartwell, that when His Grace hears music, he hears the sound of his mother’s pages burning. And then the young duchess died, too, and he shut himself up tighter than ever.”
She sighed.
“It’s a sad house, or it was. It’s been a little less sad since you came.”
Anna barely heard the last words: a music master dismissed from Ellsworth the very week the duchess’s music was burned. Her father had taught in great houses once, before she was born. He had never spoken of them. And he had tried once, he said, to return something, and they would not let him through the gate. “For my little lark,” signed simply “I,” Isabel. Anna set her cup down so suddenly that tea splashed into the saucer.
“Miss Hartwell, are you unwell?”
“No,” Anna whispered. “No, Mrs. Bell, the music master. Do you remember his name?”
Mrs. Bell frowned.
“Goodness, it was so long ago. A young man, very gentle, very kind. Always had a peppermint in his pocket for the kitchen maids. Heart something, I think. Heartley? Hartwell?”
Her eyes widened slowly as she looked at Anna’s face.
“Hartwell.”
“Oh, my dear. Oh, my dear girl.”
That night, Anna sat on the floor of the blue room with her trunk open and the silk handkerchief unfolded in her lap. The candle flickered over the old sheet of music, the faded ink, the slanting, delicate hand. “For my little lark.” The Duchess had called her son her little lark and her father had called Anna “My lark” every day of her life, perhaps without ever realizing he did it. Perhaps because the song had lived in him for so long that its words had become his own.
He had kept… Through poverty and illness and five and twenty years of silence, he had kept the one piece of Isabel Marlowe’s music that had not burned. And he had taught it to his daughter note by note so that it would not die with him. It belongs to someone. One day, perhaps, it will go home. Anna pressed the paper to her heart and wept.
She knew she must tell the Duke. But how? How did a governess walk into a Duke’s library and say, “I have a piece of your dead mother’s heart at the bottom of my trunk and my father kept it from your family for a quarter of a century”? He might think her a liar. He might think her a schemer.