“Music,” she said, “in the nursery, in this house. My goodness, I was told there was only one rule at Ellsworth, Miss Hartwell, and I believe I have just watched you break it.”

She tilted her golden head.

“I do wonder what His Grace would say.”

“My lady, please.”

“Oh, don’t trouble yourself. I shan’t tell him.”

Lady Cecily let the paper drop back onto the table. Her smile widened.

“Not yet. I find secrets so much more useful when one saves them for the proper moment.”

She turned at the door.

“What was that tune you were humming? I don’t know it. It’s rather pretty for a servant’s song.”

Anna said nothing. Lady Cecily laughed and was gone. That night, when Anna came up from supper in the servants’ hall, she found that her trunk had been opened. Nothing was badly out of place.

Not quite. But Anna had folded her shawl over the silk handkerchief at the bottom of the trunk, and now the shawl lay a little to one side. With her heart pounding, she knelt and lifted it. The silk handkerchief was there.

The sheet of music was gone. Anna searched the room twice. She searched beneath the bed and behind the washstand and inside every pocket of every dress she owned. She went down to Mrs. Bell, white to the lips, and Mrs. Bell went to Henry, and Henry said he had seen no one on the nursery stair all evening except Lady Cecily’s maid, Jenkins, who had told him she was looking for the linen cupboard and had lost her way.

“I’ll go to His Grace this minute,” said Mrs. Bell grimly.

“No,” Anna said. “No, please. If he hears of it like this, as a quarrel between a servant and a guest, he will ask what was taken, and I must tell him myself. I must tell him properly from the beginning. Please, Mrs. Bell, give me one day.”

Mrs. Bell looked at her for a long time.

“One day,” she said at last, “but I don’t like it, my dear. That young woman is up to something.”

Something became clear the very next evening. Lady Harriet had announced a musical evening. She declared that it was absurd to hold a Christmas party without music, that her brother’s foolish rule had gone on long enough, and that Lady Cecily, who had been taught by the finest masters in London, would play for the company. The duke had said nothing, but he had not forbidden it. And Mrs. Bell had stood in the gold drawing room with tears in her eyes while the footman unlocked the grand pianoforte that had been closed for five and twenty years, and the tuner from Derby worked on it all afternoon.

Anna had not meant to go downstairs at all. But at 9:00 Philippa’s bed was empty. Anna knew at once where the child had gone. All afternoon Philippa had stood at the top of the stairs listening to the tuner’s notes ring up through the old house, her small face rapt.