“Poor little mute,” she said in a voice meant to carry. “Such a pity. One does wonder whether she is quite right in the head. When I am mistress here, Lady Harriet, I think she would do very well at a good school in Bath. Somewhere far away where the quiet ones are properly managed.”

Philippa did not understand all the words, but she understood the tone. Anna felt the small body beside her go rigid and felt a cold little hand creep into hers and grip it tight. Anna looked straight up into Lady Cecily’s lovely face.

“Lady Philippa is perfectly right in the head, my lady,” she said very clearly. “She simply chooses her words with more care than some.”

There was a muffled snort from the pew in front where Henry the footman sat. Lady Cecily’s cheeks flamed scarlet. She swept on down the aisle without another word. But at the church door, she looked back and the look she gave Anna was not one Anna would forget. The duke she barely saw at all.

Lady Harriet had him occupied from morning until night. Riding with the gentlemen, dining with the ladies, escorting Lady Cecily on long walks through the portrait gallery while Lady Cecily laughed up at him and laid her small gloved hand on his arm. The evenings by the library fire stopped. Anna told herself she was glad of it. It was better.

It was right. A governess had no business at a duke’s fireside, and now she would be cured of her foolishness. She was not cured. Once, passing the open doors of the gold drawing room, she saw him standing by the fire with Lady Cecily at his side and he looked up. Over Lady Cecily’s golden head, over the whole glittering room, he found Anna in the doorway.

For 1 second, his storm gray eyes held hers and something passed across his face that looked almost like longing. Then Lady Harriet stepped between them and the doors swung shut. It was Philippa who betrayed them, not on purpose. Never on purpose.

On the fourth afternoon of the house party, Lady Cecily came up to the nursery. She came, she said brightly, at Lady Harriet’s suggestion, to become better acquainted with the dear little girl. And Anna understood at once that a future duchess was expected to show an interest in her future stepdaughter. And that Lady Cecily had no interest whatsoever.

She found Philippa and Anna at the schoolroom table with the paper pianoforte between them. Philippa’s small fingers were moving over the drawn keys. Anna, absorbed, was humming under her breath the lullaby, the strange little lift at the third note. Lady Cecily stopped in the doorway.

“Well,” she said softly, “what have we here?”

Anna’s head came up. She stood so quickly that her chair nearly toppled. Philippa snatched her hands away from the paper and shrank back against the wall. Lady Cecily strolled into the room. She picked up the paper pianoforte between two fingers, the way one might lift a dead mouse by its tail, and examined it. Then she looked at Anna and slowly she smiled.