She lifted her chin.

“When you ask me because you want to, and for no other reason at all, then I will answer you. Not before.”

He stood quite still. In the dusk, she could not see his face clearly, only the line of his jaw and the pale scar along it. Then he bowed to her, very low and very correctly, the bow of a duke to a lady, and put on his hat, and went away up the lane without another word. Inside the cottage, Nathaniel Gauntlett was not asleep. He had not been asleep since the door opened. He sat in his chair by the fire with his eyes shut and his hands folded on his blanket, and he heard every word of it through the open window.

When his son’s boots had gone away up the lane, he opened his eyes and looked into the fire for a long time. He was thinking about another evening, four summers gone, when William had come home from the rectory in the dark with a face like chalk and sat down at that same table. His mother had wept. William had not said anything. And Nathaniel, who had loved his boy more than anything on earth except the boy’s mother, had put a hand on his shoulder and said the worst thing he had ever said in his life.

“Let her be, son. A dying woman’s wish. Don’t make the girl choose between you.”

And William had let her be. He had gone back to the war the next morning and he had not come home again for 3 years. And when he came home, he was a duke and a stranger. The old man had made a joke of it now because a joke was the only door he knew how to open. He saw now that he had opened it onto a cold night for both of them.

He shut his eyes again before the girl came back in. But sleep did not come. William came down the hill the next evening as if nothing had happened at all. He said he had come to see his father and he did. The evening after he came again and this time he took off his fine coat and went out to the wood pile in his shirt sleeves and split logs until it was too dark to see.

After that, he came every evening. He never asked Sarah to step outside again. At first, they talked the way two men talk who have forgotten how, in short, stiff questions with long silences after them. But the old man had begun to eat.

And a man who eats begins to argue. And soon the cottage rang in the evenings with the two of them disagreeing about the price of wool. One afternoon at the end of that week, Sarah went up the down with a can of tea for the boy and found William already there. He was standing in the fold with his coat off and his sleeves rolled up.

One of the old ewes had rolled onto her back in a hollow and could not get up again. A cast ewe will die in a few hours if nobody finds her. The boy was hauling at her fleece, red in the face, getting nowhere. William put him gently aside.

He knelt in the wet turf, set his hands under her, and rolled her over and up onto her feet in a single easy movement that he could not have learned in any drawing room. Then he held her steady between his knees while the blood came back into her legs, talking to her the whole time under his breath in the slow, soft nonsense that shepherds talk to sheep. The boy stared at him with his mouth open. Sarah stood at the hurdle with the can of tea going cold in her hands.