“I’ll drive you,” he said. “First light.”

When she said the road was barely open he was already turning toward the yard.

“Then we’ll go slowly. Pack what you need.”

She packed her trunk that night in a quarter of an hour. It was not hard. There was not much in it. In the morning before she went down she went along the corridor and knocked at Delphine’s door. Delphine opened it and looked at the trunk in the passage behind Lydia and at the letter in her hand and understood.

“Your godmother,” she said. “Alfred’s godmother, I mean.”

“Mine too, I think,” said Lydia. “It’s Christmas Eve. Tonight, the people in the kitchen will want the Yule log lit. They’ve dragged it into the yard already. Sam says it was always done by somebody of the family.”

She hesitated.

“I won’t be here to ask, and Alfred won’t either. So, I’m asking you now. Will you light it for them?”

Delphine stood very still.

“He always lit it,” she said at last. “My husband. He made such a business of it. Speeches, a cup of ale for every man in the house.”

Her mouth trembled and was steadied.

“I have not let anyone light it since.”

“I know,” Lydia said. “That’s why I’m asking you. Somebody who loved him ought to be the one.”

Delphine was silent so long that Lydia thought she would shut the door. Then she nodded once, as if it hurt.

“Go to your old lady,” she said. “I’ll light it.”

They left Larch Hall at first light on Christmas Eve in the Duke’s traveling carriage, with the trunk strapped on behind. The Dale road was a river of slush and broken ice, and twice the men had to get down and lead the horses through floodwater that came up to the hubs. Below the narrows, the beck had come over the road altogether, and the carriage could go no further. They left it at the inn at the foot of the pass, a low stone coaching inn with a yard full of stranded carts and travelers, and the Duke hired the only fresh horse in the stable. There was no other way. He lifted Lydia up in front of him on the saddle with her cloak wrapped round both of them.

They rode down through the dusk and the flooded ford with the water rushing round the horse’s legs and her hands clenched in the front of his coat. On the far side of the ford, he drew rein under a stand of dripping trees. The rain had stopped. Far below them, where the valley opened out wide and dark, Lydia could see a few lights. One of them would be Lady Marrick’s window.

“I’m going to ask you something,” the duke said.

His voice was very low, close to her ear.

“Not the notice. Not my godmother. Me. Will you marry me, Lydia?”

She closed her eyes. She wanted to say yes so badly that it frightened her. She wanted to say it to the trees, the ford, and the dark, and have it settled for good. But, she could feel the letter in her pocket, and the trunk was back at the inn with everything she owned in it, and she was still a woman with nowhere else to go.

She would not answer him like that. She would not give him a yes that was half need. He deserved a whole one.

“Ask me again at her door,” she said. “Please. I’ll give you an answer there. I promise.”

He did not argue. He only put his arm around her a little tighter and touched his heels to the horse, and they went on down into the valley in the dark. Lady Marrick was alive. She was propped up on pillows in the big bed in her sitting room with the window by her chair standing open a crack because she had always said she could not breathe in a shut room.