“Clara Hartley, a date 1 year from today, a sum. He wrote my sister into his book of the dead before he ever stood at this altar. Listen, the notes are here, on the box, in his own hand. I did not invent them. I only heard them. Wind it again yourselves and read along and tell me I am jealous.”
The parson took the box in trembling hands and wound it and followed her page and went gray. Others came. The notes matched the page again and again in front of everyone. And no story about a jealous sister could survive a machine repeating a murdered woman’s name on demand.
Fenn ran. He did not get far. The duke had seen to the doors.
Clara, weeping, understood at last what her sister had walked into that church to do for her and threw her arms around Eleanor in front of everyone. And the whole congregation that had pitied the beauty and judged the plain one saw which sister had the greater heart.
“You knew,” Clara sobbed into her shoulder, “and he told you they would hate you, and you stood up anyway. Oh, Nell, I begged you to sit down.”
And Eleanor held her sister and said, “I know you did. You did not know what you were asking. I did. That is why it had to be me.”
Later, in the emptying church, Adrian came and stood beside Eleanor as she gathered her page of notes.
“Two years I hunted him,” he said, “every clever man of law in the county, and it was a music teacher’s ear that ended it in a quarter of an hour.”
“It was the plain sister’s ear,” Eleanor said, “the one no one ever wanted at a dance. It turns out it was for something after all.”
“Miss Hartley.” The Duke of Marban, grim no longer, looked at her the way no one had ever looked at the plain sister in her life.
“I have spent two years listening for one wrong note in a wicked man. I find I would like to spend a great many years listening to the right ones with you. I do not think you are plain. I think you are the most extraordinary person in this church, and I have met everyone in it. Would you let me court you properly?”
Eleanor Hartley, who had come only to witness her sister’s vows, looked up at him and found, to her astonishment, that the cold thing under her gladness was gone. She searched for it, the small old ache that had sat under every joy of her life, the ache of being the one no one chose, and it simply was not there. In its place was something quiet and steady, like a chord that had finally, after a lifetime, come to rest.
“I would like that, Your Grace,” she said, “but I warn you, I hear everything. You will never be able to lie to me, not even a little.”
“I am counting on it,” said the Duke.