Eleanor’s heart began to beat quickly.

“Why do you ask?”

“Because I believe he is not Aldous Fenn,” the Duke said. “I believe he is a man named Scolus, who has done this before. He finds a beautiful girl of a good but fallen family, marries her, gains control of what little the family has, and within a year the girl is dead of a wasting illness the doctors cannot name, and the grieving widower inherits and moves on to the next town under a new name.”

“Three times, Miss Hartley, that I have been able to trace. Three girls, my own cousin was the third.”

The room seemed to tilt. Eleanor put her hand on the table.

“Clara,” she whispered.

“Her name was Sophia,” the Duke went on, quieter now, and the quiet was worse than anger. “My cousin, she was 19. She wrote to me that she had met a man who made her laugh, and that for the first time since her father died she felt safe. I have that letter still. Eight months later I stood at her grave and listened to a doctor tell me that some constitutions simply fail, that there was nothing to be done, that these things happen, and the man who had married her stood beside me in black and wept the most convincing tears I ever saw, and inside a fortnight he was gone, and so was the greater part of her fortune.”

His jaw worked.

“It was 2 years before I understood I had watched a murderer cry. I have been hunting him for 2 years,” Adrian said. “I know what he does. I cannot prove who he is. He is careful. He changes his name, his story, his very handwriting between towns. There is no document, no witness who will swear, no face anyone remembers clearly enough. He is a ghost who marries girls and buries them. And in 2 days he marries your sister, and I have nothing to stop him with but a story no magistrate will hear.”

“Why me?” Eleanor asked. “Why send for me?”

“Because I have watched him for a week,” the Duke said. “And I have watched you watching him. You hear something. I saw your face at that party when he wound his music box. You heard something the rest of the room did not. I am a desperate man, Miss Hartley, and you are the only person I have found in 2 years who looked at Aldous Fenn and heard a wrong note.”

Eleanor sat down slowly, and she told him about the music box, the tune that was not a tune, the phrase that repeated, the pause that did not belong, the ending that did not resolve.

“It is not music,” she said. “It is shaped like music so that no one listens to it as anything else, but there is information in it, a pattern. I would stake my life on it. A real melody obeys rules, Your Grace, the way a sentence obeys grammar. That thing breaks every rule, but it breaks them the same way each time it plays. That is not a broken tune. That is a code wearing a tune’s clothes, and a man does not carry a coded music box for sentiment.”