The Duke of Marban rose before the first vow was spoken.

“Stop. This wedding cannot proceed.”

And the whole church turned. And he pointed not at the groom, but at the back pew, at the plain sister in the gray dress.

“The woman who can tell you why is sitting in the back of this church, though the groom has spent a great deal of money hoping she would not come.”

Fenn moved at once to control it.

“Your Grace, I do not know you. And this is my wedding day. If Miss Hartley has some grievance, we all know the sad shape of it. The plain sister, envious of the beautiful one. I forgive her. Let us continue.”

It was perfectly done. Eleanor saw the church nod, saw the pity flow toward Clara, and the cool judgment flow toward her. Exactly as he had promised. Clara’s face crumpled with hurt and embarrassment. Sit down, her eyes begged. Please, for once, do not ruin this.

For one heartbeat, Eleanor nearly did sit down. She felt the old pull to be small, to fold herself back into the shape the world found convenient. Then she thought of a brass cylinder turning in the dark with her sister’s death day cut into it. And she rose.

Eleanor stood. Her legs shook. She walked to the front of the church with every eye upon her. And she carried her page of notes. And the Duke set upon the altar rail the music box, which his men had quietly taken from Fenn’s lodgings that morning.

She saw the exact moment Fenn’s composure slipped. A stranger would have missed it. But Eleanor saw his pale gaze fall upon the little walnut box on the altar rail and go, for the space of a single breath, entirely still, the stillness of the cat, the stillness she had felt in him at the word listen. He had not known they had it. And in that one unguarded instant, she saw that everything she had reasoned in the dark before dawn was right.

“I will not ask you to believe me,” Eleanor said, and her music teacher’s voice, trained to fill a hall, filled the church. “I am the plain sister. He told me himself you would all believe I acted from envy, and he was right to think so. So, do not believe me. Believe your own ears.”

She wound the box. It played its pretty wrong little tune. And as it played, she read from her page, note by note, the cipher she had cracked before dawn. The repeated phrase, the separator, the notes between, the letters. And she read out three names and three dates and three sums and told the church plainly that these were three women married in three towns, all dead within a year, all of a wasting no doctor could name, and that if they doubted her, they might write to those towns and find the graves.

The church had gone very quiet. The pretty tune tinkled on into the silence. And now that they had been told what to listen for, Eleanor saw faces change, saw a woman near the front press a hand to her mouth, saw the four-note phrase land again and again and be heard at last for the awful mark it was. A tune they had all thought sweet a moment before now crawled upon their skins. And then she read the fourth name, freshly cut into the mechanism, and her voice did not shake anymore.