It had a phrase that repeated where no tune repeats, and a pause where no melody pauses, and it ended without resolving, hanging in the air like an unfinished sentence. The box itself was lovely, walnut and brass, small enough to sit in a man’s palm with a lid inlaid in a pattern of ivy. Clara had clasped her hands at the sight of it.

“Is it not the sweetest thing?” she had breathed. “Aldous carries it everywhere. He says the tune reminds him of his mother.”

And Fenn had bowed his head at that, a little sorrow arranged upon his face. And the ladies had all made soft sounds of sympathy. And Eleanor alone had thought, “No mother in the world sings a lullaby that will not come to rest.” It was not music. It was music-shaped. And to a woman who had spent her whole life inside real music, it was as obvious as a lie told in a language she spoke.

She had gone home that night and hummed it back to herself in the dark, unable to let it go. There it was again, the phrase that repeated, four notes, always the same four, dropped into the tune where no composer would ever put them, like a knot tied in a ribbon at regular lengths. This box repeated without answering. It was the difference between a song and a list. She thought little of it that night. She would think a great deal of it later.

The Duke of Marban was at that party, too, in a corner, watching Fenn with a stillness that Eleanor, always the observer, observed. She did not know then that he was watching the same man she was for reasons of his own, or that within a week the two of them would be the only people who could stop a wedding. She had noticed only that he did not dance, did not drink above one glass, and did not once take his eyes from the man with the music box. And that when Fenn wound the little machine, the Duke’s face had tightened as though the sweet tune caused him some private pain.

Chapter 2

The Duke found her, not the other way around. Two days before the wedding, a note came asking Eleanor to call at a solicitor’s office on a matter concerning her sister’s marriage settlement. She went, expecting some dull business about dowries. Instead, she found the Duke of Marban and a very worried lawyer and a set of documents spread across a table.

“Miss Hartley,” the Duke said.

His name was Adrian, and up close his grimness was not coldness, but worry worn deep. There were shadows under his eyes of a man who had not slept easy in a long while, and his hands, folded on the table, were not quite still.

“I am going to ask you something strange, and I need you to trust that I am not mad. The man your sister is to marry, Aldous Fenn, have you noticed anything about him that you cannot quite explain?”