And then quietly over the coming weeks try to warn Clara in private. Try to get her away. Try to save her sister without ever standing up in public to be branded a jealous liar. It might even work. It would certainly protect Eleanor from the humiliation of being disbelieved in front of everyone she knew.
She sat with the burnt-down candle and turned it over and over. She was so tired of being small. To stand up in that church was to invite them to say the word out loud in front of everyone forever. Jealous, plain, spiteful. And they would say it gladly because there is nothing a room loves so much as a story it already believes.
But she thought of the date beside Clara’s name, one year, and she thought of three other girls in three other towns who had died of a wasting no doctor could name because in each of those towns there had been no sister with a strange ear and a page of proof and a choice to make.
She was the plain sister, the one who listened while others danced. All her life that had felt like a punishment. Now she understood it had made her the one person on Earth who could hear this man for what he was. A gift is not given to be buried out of fear of being laughed at.
She would not burn the paper. She would not sit in the back and be safe. She would stand up in the church in front of everyone and let them believe the worst of her and say it anyway because a name with a date beside it is a promise. And she meant to break that promise if it cost her every last shred of what little the world had left her.
She took the paper to the Duke before dawn and told him what it said. And she told him what Fenn had threatened.
“He is right,” she said. “They will call me a jealous liar so I cannot simply speak. I need the box itself open, playing so that anyone can match the notes to the page as I read them. I need the proof to prove itself out loud where my word is not the only thing holding it up. Can you get me the box, Your Grace, in the church in front of them all?”
Adrian looked at her with something like awe.
“You would stand up in that church knowing what he will say about you?”
“I have been called the plain jealous sister my whole life without ever earning it,” Eleanor said. “I may as well earn the accusation while doing the one worthwhile thing I have ever done. Get me the box and get it open and let it sing for the whole church. He has hidden his sins in sound because he thought no one could hear. Let him learn in front of everyone that someone could.”
Chapter 4