So, when Clara wrote, breathless, that she had captured the heart of a wealthy gentleman named Mr. Aldous Fenn and that they were to marry within the month and would Eleanor please come, Eleanor packed her one good dress and went. She was glad, truly. If she felt a small cold thing under the gladness, she pushed it down because a good sister does not envy. The journey took two days by the common coach and Eleanor spent them reading Clara’s looping hand until she knew it by heart.
“He is so very kind to me,” Clara had written. “He says he cannot bear to wait.”
Eleanor had smiled at that and then frowned at it, though she could not have said why. There was a hunger in the phrase that Clara had not heard, being Clara, but that Eleanor’s ear, always turned to what lay beneath, had caught like a wrong note carried on the wind.
She met Mr. Fenn twice before the wedding. He was handsome and rich and attentive to Clara. Eleanor, who had spent her life listening, listened to him, and something in his voice troubled her the way a note slightly out of tune troubles a trained ear. She could not have said what. He was charming. He said all the right things, but he said them the way a man reads lines he has said before, in other rooms, to other people.
The first time she met him, he took her hand and told her that Clara had spoken of nothing but her clever sister, and that he counted himself fortunate to gain not one lady, but two. It was a pretty speech, and Eleanor, smiling and thanking him, heard the rhythm of it fall into place too neatly. Each phrase landing exactly where a phrase should land to please, like a musician playing a piece he has played a thousand times and no longer hears. Real warmth stumbles.
Real warmth reaches for a word and misses and laughs at itself. Fenn never missed. Every word arrived polished and on time.
“You are quiet, Miss Hartley,” he had said to her the second time, his pale eyes resting on her a moment too long. “Clara chatters like a brook, but you watch. I think you are the sort of woman who sees a great deal.”
“I only listen, sir,” she had answered.
“Ah.” He had smiled, and something behind the smile had gone still and careful, the way a cat goes still when a bird moves.
“Listening is its own kind of watching, is it not?”
He had turned the talk to other things at once, but Eleanor had not forgotten how the stillness came into him at the word listen, as though she had brushed against something he preferred kept covered. She told herself she was jealous and ashamed of it. She said nothing.
There was one strange evening. Fenn had a music box, a beautiful thing he carried with him, and he wound it for Clara at a small party, and it played a delicate little tune, and everyone cooed. Eleanor listened to the tune, and her trained ear caught something wrong with it. It was not quite a tune.