Hannah sat very still. The room seemed to tilt around her. On the coldest night of the year, on the steepest hill on the Bath Road, with the coach so heavy it had needed a fifth horse every market day for two years, Josiah Crane had refused to pay for one, to save a few shillings. Her father had not been careless. He had been sent up a frozen hill with a coach he could not hold, but she could not prove it, not yet.

The stable book showed that the cockhorse had been refused. It did not show how many people had been on the roof. The waybill said four, and it carried her father’s initials.

“No,” she whispered. “He would never have let four stand if there were more. Not him.”

And then she remembered. Her father had carried a little black notebook, no bigger than his palm. He had kept it in the inside pocket of his guard’s coat for twenty years. Every passenger he ever carried went into it, name and stage and fare, whether they were on the waybill or not.

“The proprietor keeps his bill,” he used to say. “I keep the truth. One day somebody will want to know the difference.”

When his effects had come back to her after the inquest, the notebook had not been among them. His coat had come back torn and wet. The pocket had been empty. Someone had taken it. That night, Hannah wrote a letter to Ned Quill at the Blue Lantern.

Ned had been riding on the roof as under-guard on the night of the accident. Ned had been the one who pulled her father out from under the coach. She asked him only to write to her for her father’s sake. No answer came. On the sixteenth of September, thirteen days before the auction, Lady Philippa came into the library after breakfast with two papers in her hand.

Her face was very gray. The first paper was the Bath Chronicle. On the third page, in a column of gossip from the county, there was a short paragraph. It named no one and did not need to. It spoke of a noble duke of the West Country, charmingly deceived by a young female from a coaching office, who had staged an act of great generosity on a public coach.

The second paper was worse. It was a sworn statement signed before a magistrate in Marlborough by the coachman Elias Dobbs. The duke read it standing by the window. Dobbs swore that on the evening before the journey, Miss Hannah Bell had come to him in the yard of the Blue Lantern. She had told him that the gentleman in the torn coat was the Duke of Ashcombe, for a stable boy had seen the crest on his broken carriage.

She had given Dobbs a gold sovereign to make a great noise about the gentleman’s fare at Hartley Gate, so that she might pay it in front of everyone and be remembered. At the bottom of the page, in Mr. Crane’s neat hand, someone had added a note. The sovereign she gave the coachman, it said, was very likely the same sovereign that went missing from my till. The duke put the paper down on the window seat.

“It is a lie,” he said.

“Perhaps,” said Lady Philippa. “Gabriel, I have not been unkind to that girl these last weeks. I have watched her. I confess I have half begun to like her. But you must ask yourself one question. Why would a young woman with no money and no prospects give her last coin to a stranger in a torn coat unless she had some reason to think the stranger was worth it?”