Neither of them said very much, but once, when the gig jolted over a rut, his shoulder touched hers, and he did not move away, and neither did she. That evening, Lady Philippa came to the muniment room for the first time.

“The Ellery woman tells me you found her boy,” she said.

“His Grace found him, my lady. I only knew which coach.”

Lady Philippa raised her lorgnette and looked at Hannah through it for a long moment. Then she lowered it.

“Hmm,” she said, and she went away.

It was not approval, but it was not a closed door either. The third memory of that summer was the quietest, and it was the one Hannah would keep longest. It was late in August. Rain was falling on the round window. The fire in the little grate had burned low, and the candles were guttering.

They had worked through two years of market days, and the pattern was as clear as a printed page. Hannah laid down her pen and rubbed her eyes. The duke was sitting on the other side of the hearth with his bad leg stretched out on a footstool. He was not reading. He was looking at the fire.

“May I ask you something, Your Grace?”

“You may ask.”

“Why were you on a public coach at all? Dukes don’t ride on coach roofs, not even when their axles break.”

He was silent for so long that she thought he would not answer. Then he spoke without looking at her.

“I had been to a funeral in a village called Combe Ashby on the other side of Marlborough. My old nurse. Her name was Martha. She looked after me from the day I was born until I was sent away to school at eight.” He paused. “My mother died when I was small. My father was not a man who cared for children. Martha was the only person in this house who ever sat on the end of my bed and asked me how I did.”

Hannah said nothing. She knew how to be quiet when quiet was needed.

“The funeral was at noon. My axle broke at nine. I would not have reached it in time if I had waited for the wheelwright, so I took the stage, and I stood at the back of the church in a borrowed coat, and nobody there knew who I was.” He gave a short breath that was almost a laugh. “It was the first time in my life that I was simply a man who had loved someone. Nobody bowed. Nobody asked me for anything. I found I rather liked it.”

“So when your purse was stolen—”

“I decided to stay a nobody a little longer. I wanted to know what would happen to a man who had nothing.” He looked at her at last. “Between Marlborough and Hartley Gate, Miss Bell, thirty-one people looked at me. Some of them looked away. Some of them laughed. One of them paid my fare.”

He reached into his waistcoat and drew out his watch. It hung on a plain gold chain, and from the chain beside the watch hung a small silver coin, pierced neatly through the rim, a shilling with a tiny cross scratched beside the king’s head. Hannah stared at it.

“That’s mine.”

“It was yours. I bought it back from your coachman at Kelbridge for a guinea. He thought I was mad.” He turned the coin in the firelight. “I have carried it every day since.”

“Why?”

“To remind me,” said the duke slowly, “that I was wrong. I have spent my whole life believing that every kindness has a price on it. And then a young woman with mended gloves gave away everything she had, and asked for nothing, and did not even wait to be thanked.”