He turned to face Hannah across the whole length of the room.

“I was wrong. I was more wrong than I have ever been in my life. I ask her pardon here in front of all of you, and I ask her if she is still willing to tell this trust what she came to say.”

Hannah stood very still. She had prepared herself for every kind of battle except this one. For a moment, she could not answer him at all. Then she walked to the front of the room and laid two things on the trust’s table: the Pelican’s stable book, open at the twelfth of January, and her father’s little black notebook. To her astonishment, the duke slid a third across the table toward her, a battered toll book from Hartley Gate.

She read them out, one after the other, in a clear voice that carried to the back of the room. The waybill that said four, the notebook that said eleven, name by name, the cockhorse refused by order of JC, the last ragged line in her father’s hand, God keep us all, and the tollkeeper’s note in the margin that said the same thing in fewer words. When she read the names from her father’s book, a woman on the third bench began to cry. Her husband had been the peddler. Mr. Crane was on his feet.

His soft voice was not soft any longer.

“Papers,” he said loudly. “A dead man’s scribbles and a tollkeeper’s gossip. The girl is a thief, and she has a grudge against me. Where is your proof that a single coach of mine has ever carried more than its bill?”

Hannah turned and looked out of the window. Down in the cobbled yard, the afternoon Flyer had just come in from Bath. Its horses were steaming. Its springs were sagging. Elias Dobbs was climbing down from the box.

“The Flyer has just come in, Mr. Crane,” she said. “The bill for this afternoon was written at your own desk this morning. Mr. Clerk, will you read what it says?”

The clerk sent a boy running for the waybill and read it aloud.

“Four inside, four outside.”

“Thank you,” said Hannah. “Now will everyone who can see the yard please count the roof?”

Fifty people crowded to the windows. Somebody began to count out loud, and then the whole room was counting like children in a schoolroom.

“Seven, eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve!”

Twelve people on the roof of the Flyer, and only four of them on the bill. In the yard below, Elias Dobbs looked up and saw a hundred faces in the windows of the long room, all looking at him. He stood frozen beside his horses. Then the Duke of Ashcombe opened the nearest window and leaned out.

“Mr. Dobbs,” he called down, “be so good as to come up. There is a sworn statement with your name on it that I should like to discuss.”

Dobbs came up. He came slowly, twisting his hat in his hands. He looked once at the duke and once at the crowded benches, and once, very briefly, at Mr. Crane. And then he broke.

“He paid me two guineas to swear it,” he said hoarsely. “Mr. Crane did. Wrote it all out for me, and I put my mark to it. She never spoke to me. Not once. She never knew who the gentleman was. None of us did.”

Ned Quill stepped forward, still holding the brass horn. His voice shook, but he said every word. The night on the hill, the book in his hand, the sovereign in the sewing box, and who had told him to put it there. When he had finished, there was no sound in the long room at all. Mr. Crane sat down very slowly on his bench.