“If you wish to know whether I am a thief, Your Grace,” she said, “you might simply ask me. It would be cheaper than leaving gold about the room.”
For a long moment, the duke said nothing. Then, to her surprise, a faint color came into his own face.
“That was badly done,” he said. “I apologize.”
“Why did you do it?”
“Because you were dismissed from the Blue Lantern for theft. My steward found that out in a single afternoon. And because, in my experience, Miss Bell, everyone who has ever sat in that chair has wanted something from me.”
“I wanted nothing from you. I gave you a shilling.”
“Yes,” he said quietly. “And I have spent a week trying to understand why.”
He took a bundle of papers from a drawer and laid it between them. Hannah knew those long, narrow sheets at once. Marlborough waybills, dozens of them.
“Mr. Josiah Crane holds the lease of the Blue Lantern from my estate,” the duke said. “Under that lease, he must send copies of his waybills to my steward every quarter. The estate takes a small share of every fare. Two years ago, that share was worth £1,100 a year. This year, it is worth four hundred. Mr. Crane tells my steward that the Bath Road coaches are running half empty.”
“They are not,” said Hannah.
“So you told me, on the roof. Seven people who were not on the waybill.”
“Yes.”
“Can you prove it? Not on one coach on one wet afternoon. Across two years of these.”
He touched the bundle. Hannah looked at the papers. Her fingers wanted to reach for them.
“Perhaps. If I had the stable books as well, the ostlers’ books from every stage on the road.”
“Why the stable books?”
“Because a heavy coach needs extra horses on the hills,” she said. “And extra horses must be paid for. And somebody always writes that down.”
The duke looked at her for a long moment. Something changed in his face. It was not quite a smile, but it was the first crack in the stone.
“There is more,” he said. “At Michaelmas, the Turnpike Trust will auction the tolls of the Bath Road for the next three years. Whoever wins the auction collects every toll at every gate from Marlborough to Kelbridge. Mr. Crane intends to bid. He has told half the county that he will win.”
Hannah went cold.
“If he holds the gates, no one will ever count his coaches again.”
“That,” said the duke, “is my concern exactly. I am chairman of the trust. I cannot stop a man from bidding because I dislike his smile. I need evidence, and I need it before the twenty-ninth of September.”
“And you want me to find it.”
“I am offering you a position as a clerk to this estate at forty pounds a year, with a room in this house and a written character at the end of it, whatever you find. Will you take it?”
Forty pounds was more than her father had earned in his best year. But Hannah thought of the inquest and of Mr. Crane with his hat held to his chest.
“I have a condition,” she said.
One dark eyebrow rose.
“I am listening.”
“My father died on Hartley Hill on the twelfth of January. The coroner said he was drunk and careless. He was neither. If I find what you need, Your Grace, then I want his name cleared publicly, where everyone who heard the lie can hear the truth.”
“The coroner’s verdict has been entered, Miss Bell. It is not a simple thing to open again.”