The duke did not answer.

“I am not saying it is true,” his aunt said more gently. “I am saying the county will believe it. And in thirteen days, you must refuse a man’s bid on the word of a girl he has accused of theft.”

She left him alone. The duke stood at the window for a long time. He took out his watch and looked at the little shilling on its chain. He thought of the coach roof. He thought of the way she had counted all day, her lips moving.

She had told him herself. She had been watching everyone. Had she been watching him too? He thought of his father, who had told him at the age of seven that every smile in this house had a price on it. He had believed it for twenty-five years.

And then a girl with mended gloves had made him stop. And now he could feel the old belief coming back, cold and patient, like water rising in a cellar. He went up to the muniment room at four that afternoon. Hannah was at the trestle table. She looked up when he came in, and her face lit with something she did not try to hide.

“I’ve found the twelfth of January,” she said. “Mr. Crane refused the cockhorse on the coldest night of the year. My father couldn’t have held that coach. Nobody could. Now, if I can only find his notebook—”

She stopped. She had seen his face.

“What is it?”

He laid Dobbs’s statement on the table in front of her. He did not say anything. He watched her read it. She read it once, then she read it again, more slowly. All the color went out of her face.

When she looked up, her eyes were very dark.

“This is not true,” she said.

“I know what it says. I want to hear what you say.”

“I’ve just said it. It is not true. I never spoke to Dobbs in my life except to give him a waybill. I didn’t know who you were. I didn’t know until I walked into your library.”

The duke was silent. And in that silence, Hannah understood something that made her feel colder than she had ever felt on any coach roof.

“You’re not sure,” she said slowly.

“Hannah—”

“No. You came up those stairs to ask me. You read that paper and you came up here to look at my face and see if I was lying.”

Her voice was quite steady. That was the worst of it.

“That’s what the purse was on the first day, and this is the purse again.”

“That is not fair.”

“Isn’t it?”

She stood up.

“Ask me, then. Ask me properly. I’d like to hear you say it.”

He held her gaze. Then, very quietly, as if the words were dragged out of him, he said it.

“Did you know who I was on the coach?”

Hannah closed her eyes for a moment. When she opened them, they were dry.

“No,” she said. “I did not know. I did not care. I would have done exactly the same if you had been a tinker or a sweep. That is the whole point of it, Your Grace. That is the only point there ever was.”

“Then why?”

“Because no one should be left at the roadside.” Her voice cracked at last, just once. “I thought you understood that. I thought, of everyone in the world, you did.”

She turned back to the table and began very neatly to gather up the waybills and tie them into their bundles.