“Right,” Roy said with the particular tone of a man who has found something amusing and is working very hard not to show it.
“Right. I’ll take Hector.”
Sheriff Dale Holt was a thoughtful man who’d held his position for 11 years by the simple virtue of listening more than he talked and making decisions slowly enough that he rarely had to unmake them. He received Caleb and Eleanor in his office on Tuesday morning, read the documentation twice, and asked Eleanor six questions about her observations at the fire site. She answered all six with the same precision she’d used writing them down. Holt set the papers on his desk and tapped the edge of them with one finger.
“The char pattern you’re describing, you’ve seen arson before. Miss Whitfield.”
“My uncle was a volunteer fire warden in Columbus for 12 years,” she said. “I spent enough time listening to him that I know the difference between an accidental fire and a deliberate one.”
“Hmm.”
Holt looked at Caleb.
“You’re naming Blackwell.”
“I’m presenting evidence,” Caleb said. “I’m letting you draw conclusions.”
Holt almost smiled.
“That’s diplomatically put.”
He leaned back in his chair.
“I’ve had two complaints from Blackwell in the past 4 months, both regarding your northwest fence line. The timing of this coming now with fresh documentation on your side.”
He paused.
“I’m not prepared to accuse a man without more, but I am prepared to pay him a visit and make it clear that the matter of the Harrison property lines is officially documented and legally established. Sometimes that’s the thing that settles an itch.”
“And if it doesn’t settle it?” Eleanor asked.
Holt looked at her with what appeared to be mild surprise. The surprise of a man unaccustomed to women asking follow-up questions in official settings.
“Then we deal with whatever comes next,” he said. “One step at a time, ma’am.”
Eleanor held his gaze just a beat longer than was entirely comfortable. Then,
“Of course, Sheriff. Thank you for your time.”
Outside on the boardwalk, Caleb glanced at her.
“You don’t trust him.”
“I trust that he’s a cautious man,” she said, “and that cautious men in small towns are often more responsive to social pressure than to evidence. The question is, who holds more social pressure in this county, you or Blackwell?”
She looked at him.
“Do you know the answer to that?”
He considered.
“Depends on the room.”
“Then you need to make sure you’re in the right rooms before Blackwell figures out the fire didn’t work.”
She started walking toward the wagon.
“We should pay a call on Mr. and Mrs. Aldridge this week. You mentioned Tom Aldridge is the county assessor. What’s his wife’s name?”
“Margaret,” Caleb said, keeping pace.
“Why?”
“Because the men in this town talk to each other,” Eleanor said. “But the women know what’s actually happening. And Margaret Aldridge has a position in this community that carries weight.”
She glanced at him.
“Do you object to a social call?”