“He’s never used that land.”

“He needs to prove he has, or he needs to prevent you from proving he hasn’t.”

She looked at him steadily.

“How well documented is your own use of the northwest section?”

“Roy moves the breeding mares there every June for the summer grass. Has for 6 years. It’s in my operation logs.”

“Where are the operation logs?”

He crossed to the filing cabinet and opened the bottom drawer. He pulled out a stack of ledger books thick, worn, dated on the spines. He handed them to her. She took them and began going through them immediately turning pages with focused speed.

“Here,” she said 3 minutes later, “June of ’78, moved 14 mares to northwest pasture. Here ’79, same entry. ’80, ’81, ’82.”

She looked up.

“Six consecutive entries dated, initialed by Roy, recorded in your operational ledger.”

She held it up.

“This is your counter evidence.”

Caleb looked at the ledger, then at her.

“Is it enough?”

“It’s a strong foundation, but we need more than the ledger. We need corroborating witnesses who can attest to having seen the mares on that section. We need Roy’s formal statement. We need to get this to a proper land attorney before Blackwell’s filing date settles into the official record.”

She set the ledger down carefully.

“And we need to move fast because Blackwell filed this morning and every day we wait is a day he has to shore up his version.”

Caleb crossed his arms over his chest. He looked at the organized spread of papers across his office at what she’d done in the hour and a half since Finch had left and something moved through his expression that wasn’t quite the thing she’d seen in the stable but was in the same family.

“You started pulling this the moment he left,” Caleb said.

“Yes.”

“Before I knew about it.”

“I didn’t know when you’d be back and we couldn’t afford to lose the afternoon.”

He was quiet for a moment.

“I went to Blackwell alone before,” he said. “Without telling you.”

She met his eyes.

“I’m telling you now,” she said. “Before I’ve done anything past pulling the files. Because you were right that I should have been consulted before you went to him and I should practice what I required of you.”

The room was very still.

“What do you recommend?” he asked.

She’d been waiting for that question, had prepared for it, but the simple directness of it still landed somewhere real.

“Ride to Billings,” she said, “tomorrow morning. There’s a firm there, Aldrich and Moore. Tom Aldridge mentioned them at dinner as having handled a similar case in the Yellowstone Valley 2 years ago. Take the ledgers, take the documentation from the fire night, take Roy’s signed statement, and two other witnesses who’ve seen the mares on that section.”

She paused.

“And take me.”

He looked at her.

“You’ll want someone in that meeting who has read Finch’s filing completely and can answer detailed questions about the documentary record,” she said.