“You all right, miss?” Mrs. Greer said without turning from the stove.

“Yes,” Eleanor said.

“Then, no, not entirely.”

Mrs. Greer turned. She looked at Eleanor with the direct practical appraisal that was her version of tenderness.

“You need to eat something.”

“Probably,” Eleanor said.

“Sit still,” Mrs. Greer said and put a plate of biscuits on the table.

“Whatever it is can wait 10 minutes.”

Eleanor sat still. She ate a biscuit. She thought about Dorothea Ames making herself write that letter. She thought about the specific courage it took to acknowledge a damage you’d failed to prevent.

She thought that maybe the world was slightly less indifferent to justice than she’d concluded. She was still sitting there when Caleb came in from the morning work. He looked at her. One look, the look he’d developed over these weeks, the one that read the temperature of her without asking.

“What happened?” he said.

She handed him the letter. He read it. She watched his face while he read, saw the jaw set, saw the moment he reached the part about the deliberate defamation, saw something come into his eyes that was not quite anger because it was too quiet and too deep for that. He set the letter down. He looked at her.

“Five years,” he said. “He let you carry that for 5 years.”

“Yes.”

“And she knew.”

His voice was even, but barely.

“His wife.”

“She watched it happen. She’s trying to correct it now.”

“Five years late.”

“Yes.”

Eleanor paused.

“But she’s trying.”

She looked at her coffee.

“I’ve been angry at her for the five years she didn’t say anything. I’m trying to leave room for the fact that she’s saying it now.”

Caleb looked at her that full direct look.

“You’re more generous than I am.”

“I’ve had more practice at needing to be.”

He was quiet for a moment. Then,

“This statement she’s offering, is it useful for the situation here with Blackwell?”

Eleanor looked at him. She hadn’t thought of it that way. She turned it over now carefully.

“Not directly. The Blackwell situation is about land title, not personal character. But…”

She paused.

“If he continues to attack my credibility as part of his campaign, if he argues in front of the commission that my documentation is unreliable because of my personal history, a formal attestation from a witness to the original defamation would counter that directly.”

Caleb nodded.

“Write back and ask for it.”

“I already did,” she said.

He looked at her.

“Before you thought through whether it was useful.”

“Before I thought through anything really. I just knew it was the right answer to give her.”

He was quiet. Then he said,

“Good.”

In the particular way he said that word, not as praise exactly, but as recognition. The recognition of something done correctly for its own sake. The thing Blackwell did next came eight days before the hearing, and it was the one Eleanor had not predicted. He didn’t go after the land. He didn’t go after the witnesses. He went after the arrangement itself, but sideways and through a channel that had not been on her map.