The handwriting was unfamiliar. She opened it at the kitchen table while Mrs. Greer was working at the stove, and she read it once, and then she set it on the table very carefully, the way you set something down when your hands are not entirely steady. She picked it up and read it again. It was from a woman named Dorothea Ames writing from Columbus, Ohio. She identified herself as the wife of the merchant’s son, the man who had 5 years ago had Eleanor dismissed and then ensured her professional reputation in Columbus was destroyed.
Her letter was two pages long and shaking in its handwriting in a way that suggested it had been written and rewritten and was the product of a decision that had cost something real. She wrote that she had seen a notice, some social correspondence that had made its way east through the mail order agency network that Eleanor Whitfield had settled in Montana territory. She wrote that she had been carrying something for 3 years and had not known what to do with it. She wrote that her husband had in fact spread deliberate falsehoods about Eleanor’s character to multiple employers in Columbus after Eleanor’s dismissal and that she had witnessed this and had said nothing. And that the silence had become something she could no longer carry.
She wrote that if Eleanor needed a formal statement to that effect, a written attestation to the deliberate defamation, she would provide one. That it was the least she could do. Eleanor sat with the letter for a long time. Mrs. Greer, who had been quietly present in the way that older women are present when they understand something is happening, set a cup of coffee next to Eleanor’s elbow without a word and went back to the stove. Eleanor picked up the coffee.
She thought about 5 years of careful management and strategic composure and the specific exhausting discipline of building a life on the only materials left after someone has deliberately taken most of them. She thought about the merchant’s son’s face, smug and certain, the face of a man who knew that his damage would hold because there was no mechanism for her to undo it. She thought about sitting in this kitchen 3 weeks ago preparing for a dinner that was really a defensive campaign. She thought about standing on the street of Harlow Creek and choosing again not to be undone by a man who expected it.
She set the coffee down and picked up a pen. She wrote back to Dorothea Ames. She thanked her. She asked plainly and without drama for the formal written statement.
She said she would cover any costs associated with notarizing it. She said she understood what it had taken to write the letter, and that she didn’t take it lightly. She sealed it before she thought too much about what she was doing, and put it with the outgoing post. Then she sat with her coffee and realized her hands were shaking slightly.