“That’s me.”

Caleb held her gaze for a long moment. Then,

“Can you be ready to leave at first light?”

“I’ll be ready at first light,” she said.

They left at 5:30 the following morning before the sun had fully cleared the eastern hills. Roy had given his formal statement the night before signed and witnessed, and had added with characteristic directness that he’d watched Blackwell’s cattle on the northwest section exactly twice in 6 years, both times straying through a broken fence, and that he’d sent the cattle back across both times, and had the dates recorded in his own work diary. He added the diary to the evidence file without being asked. Caleb drove. Eleanor sat beside him with the satchel of documents across her knees and her hands folded on top of it, and they moved through the early morning in the particular quiet of people who have been through enough together that silence between them no longer needs filling. After about half an hour, Caleb said,

“There’s something I haven’t told you.”

She looked at him.

“The northwest section,” he said, “Blackwell’s wanted it for years, you know that. But there’s a reason beyond the water rights that I’ve never made public.”

He kept his eyes on the road.

“When I first came to Montana, before the ranch was fully established, when I was still running on borrowed money and borrowed time, I had a partner. His name was Arden Cole. We bought the original land together.”

He paused.

“Arden died in the winter of ’75, influenza. He was 29.”

His voice was measured, but Eleanor could hear beneath the measure of it something that hadn’t been said to many people.

“He died before the northwest section was fully developed. That land what it’s become, I built it after he was gone, for both of us.”

Eleanor said nothing for a moment.

“The northwest section is the most productive land on the property,” he continued.

“That’s partly the water access, partly the grass, but it’s also I’ve run it harder than any other section, put more into it.”

He paused.

“I’ll lose cases in court that I can replace. That one I won’t.”

“I understand,” she said, quietly, simply, not reaching for more than he’d offered.

He glanced at her.

“I know you do.”

They rode on. The law offices of Aldrich and Moore occupied the upper floor of a brick building on the main street of Billings. James Moore, the active partner, a compact man in his 50s with wire-rimmed spectacles and the unhurried manner of a person who is very good at his work and has no need to demonstrate it, received them in his office at 11:00. He read the Finch filing first, then the ledgers, then Roy’s statement, then Eleanor’s documentation from the fire night, and here he paused reading it twice and then looked up at her.

“You wrote this,” he said.

“Yes, sir.”

“The night of the fire.”

“Before midnight, yes.”

He looked at her over his spectacles with an expression of professional evaluation.