“I know, boss. What are you going to do about it?”

And Caleb said quietly,

“I’m going to find out where it started, and I’m going to end it.”

He did not consult Eleanor before going to see Victor Blackwell. He would realize later that this was the first mistake, not the going, the not consulting. He found Blackwell at his ranch in the yard, overseeing the shoeing of a horse. Blackwell saw him coming and took his time straightening up. He was the kind of man who always made sure he was the one who decided when a conversation started.

“Harrison,” he said, “didn’t expect a house call.”

“I’ll say this once,” Caleb said.

He kept his voice level. He’d learned a long time ago that a raised voice was a signal that you’d already partly lost.

“The stories going around town about Miss Whitfield are lies. You know they’re lies. Anyone with half a mind knows they’re lies. If I hear them again from any direction in any form, I’ll take it as a direct statement of intent, and I’ll respond to it accordingly.”

Blackwell looked at him with a slow, considered calm.

“That sounds like a threat, Caleb.”

“It’s a statement of fact,” Caleb said. “There’s a difference.”

Blackwell smiled that wide, empty, social smile.

“You’ve gotten sentimental over a mail-order woman.”

He shook his head like he was genuinely sad about it.

“She’s gotten into your head.”

“She’s gotten into my books,” Caleb said. “And as a result, my operation is running 20% cheaper than it was in June. That’s not sentiment, Victor. That’s good sense.”

He picked up his reins.

“The stories stop.”

He rode back. He thought that was the end of it. It was not the end of it. What he’d failed to consider, what he understood only when he walked into the kitchen that evening and found Eleanor standing very still at the window with her arms folded across her chest and an expression on her face that he had not seen before, was that Eleanor had heard about the stories before he had. She had heard them, and she had not told him. And when she found out he’d gone to Blackwell, something in that careful, precise, managed composure of hers had cracked straight down the middle.

“You went to him,” she said.

It wasn’t a question.

“Yes,” he said.

“Without telling me.”

Her voice was flat, controlled, but under it something was shaking.

“I didn’t want you to have to…”

“To what?”

She turned from the window. Her eyes were bright, not with tears, not with the softness of someone about to cry, but with the particular brightness of someone who is working very hard to contain something enormous.

“To be involved in my own defense. To have information about what’s being said about me. To be consulted before a decision was made that directly concerns my reputation.”

“Eleanor,”

“I have been managing what people say about me since I was 22 years old,” she said.