He thought about the last social call he’d made, which had been approximately 3 years ago at Roy’s insistence, and had mostly consisted of him standing in someone’s parlor holding a hat and contributing very little.

“I’m not skilled at them,” he admitted.

“I know,” she said. “That’s why I’ll conduct it and you’ll nod and look dependable.”

He stopped walking. She walked three more steps before she realized he’d stopped and she turned. He was looking at her with an expression he wasn’t quite managing to keep neutral.

“Did you just tell me to stand there and look dependable?”

“Yes.”

She tilted her head.

“Can you do that?”

He opened his mouth, closed it.

“Good,” she said and turned back toward the wagon.

Caleb Harrison, who had faced down three rustlers, two floods, one bank foreclosure, and a particularly aggressive bull stood on the main street of Harlow Creek and felt for the first time in years something that was startlingly close to laughter working its way up through his chest. He didn’t let it out, but it was there. The call on Margaret Aldridge happened on Thursday afternoon. Caleb sat in the Aldridge’s parlor with his hat on his knee and said very little. Eleanor talked. Not about Blackwell, not about the fire, not about anything that could be characterized as complaint or grievance.

She talked about the ranch, about her initial impressions of Montana, about the differences between Ohio summers and these ones. She asked questions about the community, who was new, who had been there for generations, what the town needed, what people were proud of. She listened in a way that made people want to keep talking. Margaret Aldridge, who was a perceptive woman and a social institution in Harlow Creek, was watching Eleanor the way a craftsperson watches another person work with a professional appraisal that was rapidly becoming approval. When they left, Tom Aldridge shook Caleb’s hand on the front step and said quietly,

“Fine woman you’ve got there, Caleb. Sharp as a tack and not obnoxious about it. That’s rare,” Caleb said, “I know.”

He did know. That was the thing. He was knowing it more each day, and the knowing was becoming something he didn’t have a clean category for. The second time Blackwell moved against them, he was smarter about it.

No fire, no direct action. Instead, 3 weeks after the night of the attempted burning, a story began circulating in town. Caleb didn’t hear it directly. He heard it from Roy, who had heard it from Hector, who’d heard it at the saloon.

The story was that Eleanor Whitfield, before she’d come to Montana, had been dismissed from not one, but two positions for dishonesty. That she’d had a child out of wedlock that she’d abandoned. That the reason no man in Ohio had married her was not circumstance, but character. None of it was true.

Caleb knew it wasn’t true, not because he could prove it in that moment, but because he knew Eleanor, and the woman he knew was many things, complicated things, guarded things, but she was not those things. He knew it the way you know the particular weight of a fence post you’ve carried a hundred times, not from looking at it, but from the feel of it in your hands. He told Roy that. Roy said,