“Did she?”
“She told me you’d sworn never to marry after your father died. She said you’d sworn it on his coffin.”
He stopped walking.
“Is it true?”
Alice stared at him.
“No,” she said. “No. Why would she say that? I never swore anything. I never said anything like it. I was going to…”
She stopped.
“You were going to what?” the Duke said gently.
Alice looked at the wall. At the pear tree bare now with a few last yellow leaves on it.
“I was going to marry him,” Alice said. “Julian. He asked me two years ago here, right here by this tree. I told him I couldn’t leave my father. I told him to ask me again when Papa was gone. I promised him I’d say yes.”
She pressed her hand against the cold stone of the wall.
“And then Papa died, and Julian came home, and he never asked.”
The Duke did not say anything for a long moment.
“Miss Fenwick,” he said slowly, “where were you the day he came home?”
“I don’t know,” Alice said. “I never saw him come. The first I knew, he was at the inn. I thought he’d seen me in the village somewhere and changed his mind.”
“And your sister,” the Duke said, “where was she?”
Alice turned round.
Aunt Mab was waiting for her on the landing when she came in, sitting in the dark in the window seat with a shawl around her shoulders and the brass ear trumpet in her lap.
“Sit down,” Aunt Mab said. “Here next to me.”
Alice sat down.
“I’m deaf,” Aunt Mab said. “Everybody knows I’m deaf. Everybody shouts at me. And because I’m deaf, nobody ever bothers to lower their voice when I’m in the room.”
She tapped the ear trumpet.
“I’m not as deaf as all that, Alice. Not when it suits me.”
“Aunt Mab…”
“Your sister was in the drawing room this afternoon,” Aunt Mab said, “with your brother-in-law. They didn’t know I was behind the screen. I was asleep. Or they thought I was.”
She took a breath.
“He asked her about the Duke. Why the Duke was always with you. He sounded jealous. Not of the Duke, of you.”
Aunt Mab looked straight at her niece.
“And she said, ‘Don’t be silly, Julian. Alice swore on Papa’s coffin she’d never marry. You know that. I told you at the gate.'”
Alice did not move.
“And he said,” Aunt Mab went on very quietly, “‘I’ve never asked her about it. Not once. I couldn’t bear to hear her say it.’ And your sister said, ‘Then don’t. Please don’t ever. It would break her heart.'”
The landing was completely dark except for the moon through the window.
“At the gate,” Alice said. “In May.”
“At the gate,” said Aunt Mab. “While you were in the village paying your father’s doctor.”
Alice sat on the window seat and looked at the door of the best bedroom across the landing, her father’s room, where her sister was sleeping now in her father’s bed beside the man who had waited 2 years for Alice Fenwick and been told by the one person he had no reason to doubt that she had sworn never to have him.
“He’s married her,” Alice said.