The night before the wedding, Alice could not sleep. She went down to the kitchen at midnight to make herself a cup of tea. Mrs. Tilly was still up sitting by the range in her nightcap, doing nothing. Mrs. Tilly had cooked for the Fenwicks for 26 years.
She had cooked for Alice’s christening. She had cooked the soup that Alice carried up to her father every night for 11 years, and she had cried at the funeral louder than anyone.
“Can’t sleep either, Miss Alice?” Mrs. Tilly said.
“No,” Alice said.
Mrs. Tilly got up and put the kettle on. She did it slowly. She was 64 and her knees were bad.
“I’ll tell you something,” Mrs. Tilly said with her back to Alice. “And then I’ll never say it again, and you can box my ears if you like. It should have been you tomorrow. Everybody in this kitchen knows it should have been you.”
Alice did not say anything.
“Miss Cecily is a pretty girl,” Mrs. Tilly said. “And I’ve known her since she was born, and I’m fond of her. But I watched that young man walk you home from church every Sunday for a year. And I’ve watched him with her all summer. And he doesn’t look at her the way he looked at you. Not once. Not one single time.”
She put the teapot down harder than she meant to.
“Something’s wrong with it, Miss Alice. I don’t know what, but something’s wrong.”
“He’s chosen,” Alice said quietly. “That’s all. People are allowed to choose.”
“Hm,” Mrs. Tilly said.
She poured the tea. They drank it together by the range, not talking until the kitchen clock struck one.
So, there she was on her sister’s wedding day at the door with her arms full of wet coats. The last guests were coming up the path. Alice could hear the wedding breakfast starting in the dining room behind her. Glasses, laughter, somebody tapping a spoon for a toast.
She had not been given a place at the table. She had checked the cards that morning while she was setting them out. Her name was not on any of them. When she asked, Cecily had said,
“Oh, Ally, I thought you’d want to be in and out keeping an eye on things. You’d hate to be stuck at the table all afternoon.”
And she had kissed her and gone upstairs to have her hair done. So Alice stood at the door, and the last guest came up the path alone. He was a tall man, older than the others, perhaps 45. He had no umbrella. The rain had soaked through the shoulders of his dark coat and turned his hair, which was black going gray, flat against his head.
He walked slowly, as if he were not sure he wanted to arrive. Alice did what she had done for every other guest that afternoon. Before he could even take off his hat, she reached out and brushed the rain off his shoulders with her hand. First one shoulder, then the other. Quick and firm, the way she had brushed her father’s coat a thousand times.
“There,” Alice said. “You’re soaked. Let me take that.”
The man went completely still. He looked down at her hand on his sleeve. Then he looked at her face. He looked at it for so long that Alice took her hand away and felt her cheeks go hot.