“I can’t,” Alice had said. “Not while he’s alive. I can’t leave him.”

“Then I’ll wait,” Julian had said.

“Julian, it could be years.”

“Then I’ll wait years.”

She had laughed at him. She had cried a little, too. And then she had said the thing she remembered afterwards, every day for 2 years.

“Ask me again,” Alice said. “When he’s gone. Ask me again and I’ll say yes. I promise you I’ll say yes before you’ve finished the question.”

He had kissed her hand. He had gone north the next week. He wrote to her every month. She kept every letter in a box under her bed.

She did not tell anyone about the promise. It felt wrong somehow to talk about the day after your father died while he was still breathing in the room above you. She did not know that her sister had been standing on the other side of the garden wall that evening picking pears. Cecily had heard every word.

Their father died on a cold night in March. Alice was holding his hand. He woke up for a few minutes near the end, the way people sometimes do, and he knew her. He said her name. He said,

“You’ve been good to me, Ally.”

Then he went back to sleep, and a little before dawn, he stopped breathing.

The will was read the week after the funeral. It was an old will. He had made it years before when he was still well. It said that the house and everything in it would go to whichever of his daughters married first.

The other daughter was to have a home in it for as long as she lived. The lawyer explained it. Their father had been worried, he said, that neither girl would ever marry. He had wanted to give them a reason. And he had wanted to be sure that whichever one married, the other would be looked after.

“He was thinking of you, Miss Fenwick,” the lawyer said to Alice kindly. “Mostly of you, I think. He knew about Mr. Hart.”

Alice smiled. She did not say anything. She was thinking of June, of the pear tree, of Julian coming home in two months’ time and asking her again and her saying yes before he had finished the question. Cecily did not smile. Cecily sat very still in her black dress and looked at her own hands.

Julian Hart came home at the end of May. He did not write first. He wanted to surprise her. He took the coach from the north and then a hired horse from the town and he rode up to the gate of the Fenwick house on a bright afternoon with his heart going like a drum.

Alice was not at the gate. Alice was in the village that afternoon at the old doctor’s house paying the last of her father’s bills. Cecily was at the gate. She was cutting roses.

She was wearing a pale blue dress that was not quite mourning. She looked up when she heard the horse, and she saw who it was, and she put down her basket. What Cecily said to Julian Hart at the gate that afternoon took 4 minutes. Nobody else heard it. Alice would not hear about it for four more months.