He stopped in the parlor doorway and did not come in and did not go away either. And behind him, coming up the path in the rain in her lilac silk dress with no cloak over it, was Cecily. Nobody said anything for what felt like a very long time. Cecily came in past the Duke.

She did not look at him. She stood just inside the parlor door with the rain dripping off her hair and her silk dress soaked dark across the shoulders. She looked at her husband. Then she looked at her sister.

“I’ll say it,” Cecily said. “Don’t make her say it, Julian. She’s never had to say anything in her life. I’ll say it.”

She took a breath.

“Alice never swore on Papa’s coffin,” Cecily said. “She never said she wouldn’t marry. She never asked me to tell you anything. She was in the village that day paying Dr. Webb. She didn’t know you were home.”

Her voice did not shake at all. It was very flat and very clear.

“I heard you ask her by the pear tree two summers ago. I heard her say yes. And when you came back, I got to the gate first and I lied to you. That’s all. That’s the whole of it.”

Julian sat down on Aunt Mab’s footstool as if his legs had gone. Aunt Mab lowered her ear trumpet slowly into her lap.

“Why are you telling him?” Alice said to her sister. “I promised you I wouldn’t.”

“I know you did,” Cecily said. “That’s why.”

She looked at the floor.

“You walked out of that house with one trunk, Ally. You didn’t take anything. Not the silver, not the pictures, not mama’s pearls. You took Papa’s watch and a pair of old gloves. And every single person who worked in that house walked out after you.”

She pressed her lips together.

“I stood in the hall on Saturday night and it was so quiet and I thought, ‘This is what I did it for. This house, and it’s empty. There’s nobody in it but me.'”

Nobody said anything.

“I don’t know how to be good,” Cecily said. “I never learned. You were always the one who was good. But I know how to stop lying. That much I can do.”

Julian looked up at Alice from the footstool.

“You were waiting for me,” he said. “The whole time, you were going to say yes.”

“I was,” Alice said.

She said it plainly. She did not soften it. He had the right to hear it plainly.

“Two years ago,” Alice said, “I would have walked to the north with you on my bare feet. I would have said yes before you’d finished the question. That’s the truth, Julian. I won’t pretend it isn’t.”

Julian put his face in his hands.

“But you married my sister,” Alice said, “in a church. I heard you make the promises, and she’s just stood in this room in the rain and told the truth when she didn’t have to. That’s the first brave thing I’ve ever seen her do.”

She looked at Cecily.

“So, you’ll keep those promises, both of you. You’ll go home and you’ll learn how to be married to each other. Not the way it should have been. The way it is.”